
Two Simard Westlink trucks moved ten containers in Port Coquitlam without entering a marine terminal. Even the goods they carried never passed through one. The B.C. Court of Appeal nevertheless upheld the trucking commissioner’s decision that regulated driver rates applied to the licensed carrier’s trips with qualifying containers.
In Simard Westlink Inc. v Office of the British Columbia Container Trucking Commissioner, 2026 BCCA 442, Simard argued that applying minimum rates to a licensed company while allowing an unlicensed competitor to do the same inland work at a different rate undermined the legislation. Justice Willcock, writing for a unanimous panel, held that the commissioner had addressed that objection and reasonably explained how the distinction fit the licensing scheme. The court dismissed the appeal under the statutory test of patent unreasonableness.
Why the containers qualified
The investigation began with trips on March 15, 2023, using trucks that lacked the required tags. Simard argued that the moves were domestic and that the sites and containers fell outside the regulation. The commissioner reasoned that a licence gives its holder access to marine-terminal work and also obliges it to pay prescribed rates when it moves qualifying containers between facilities in the Lower Mainland.
The regulation defines a container by whether an ocean carrier furnished or approved it for marine transport. The commissioner concluded that a particular load’s destination or domestic contents did not change that approval. He excluded containers whose safety certification plates had expired. The appeal court also observed that other features, such as a four-letter identification code, could indicate approval for marine use.
Simard’s interpretation would have required auditors to trace each container’s journey to decide whether the same rail yard counted as a regulated facility. The commissioner found that approach hard to enforce and inconsistent with the aim of ensuring drivers receive the prescribed rates for off-dock work.
What the earlier audit told Simard
Simard also argued that it had relied on an earlier audit and regulatory guidance when setting its rates. In April 2020, however, the commissioner sent the company a letter distinguishing the completed audit from its future obligations. He told Simard he would leave the audit findings in place and reminded it to adjust its pay structure in light of a new industry bulletin.
The court agreed that Simard had received no clear assurance exempting the trips at issue. The commissioner had allowed the company to exclude 53-foot containers from its retrospective payroll review, but Willcock described that as a discretionary concession in light of possible confusion about those containers.
In the underlying February 2024 reconsideration, the commissioner ordered Simard to pay one driver $114.12 for the day in question. He also directed a payroll review covering September 2019 to August 2023 and reduced the administrative penalty to $8,000. The appeal court’s September 23 decision left that ruling in place.
Sources: Court of Appeal decision on CanLII · Court of Appeal reasons · Commissioner’s reconsideration decision.



