A Manitoba court has dismissed a student’s standalone application for all of a college’s records about her, finding that the civil discovery rules she relied on did not provide a legal basis for the request.

Justice Toews ruled that Hulya Gullu could not use that application to compel disclosure from Providence University College and Theological Seminary. She had not started an action against the college.

The September 28 decision, Gullu v. Providence University College and Theological Seminary, 2026 MBKB 134, left open the possibility that she could seek relevant documents through other court or tribunal proceedings she had already begun.

Discovery depends on the proceeding

Gullu sought records covering essentially every aspect of her relationship with the college, where she had been a student. She relied on Rules 1.03 and 30.02 of Manitoba’s Court of King’s Bench Rules.

The discovery rule requires parties to an action to disclose relevant documents and to produce relevant, non-privileged documents for inspection. The rules’ definition of an action excludes a proceeding begun by application.

The college argued that relevance is ordinarily assessed against the issues identified in the parties’ pleadings. With no action between Gullu and the college, there were no pleadings defining the issues against which the requested records could be assessed.

Gullu had brought other proceedings arising primarily from an incident at a flight school. The court noted that the flight school was separate from the college, which did not control it and was not a party to those lawsuits.

The college said it had voluntarily provided substantially all of the requested records and had made extensive efforts to accommodate her requests. Those statements were the college’s position, rather than a finding that every potentially relevant document had been supplied.

Application dismissed with costs

Toews accepted the college’s legal position and found no statutory or common-law basis for compelling production through this application. The reasons do not decide what disclosure Gullu might obtain in another proceeding.

The application was dismissed with costs payable to the college under the applicable tariff. If the parties could not agree on the amount, the judge directed them to make brief written submissions.