
A social media manager working on a Montreal-area television production was an employee for employment-insurance purposes, the Tax Court of Canada has ruled, despite the production company’s intention to treat its workers as independent contractors.
In Harshita v. M.N.R., 2026 TCC 179, issued October 16, Justice Lara G. Friedlander found that close supervision, controlled working hours and limited opportunity for profit or loss outweighed features pointing toward independent business activity.
The court allowed Harshita Harshita’s appeal without costs and varied the minister’s decision to recognize insurable employment from January 4, 2023, to May 25, 2024. It did not award benefits or decide a dismissal claim.
Different expectations about the working relationship
Les Productions Beauty World Search Inc. hired Harshita to create and manage social media content for the second season of The Fashion Hero. After three months of training in Laval, she worked from home, producing posts and videos, responding to public queries and managing other aspects of the program’s online presence.
She invoiced for her time and used her own laptop. But the company supplied paid content-production applications, set weekly targets and posting dates, reviewed her work before publication and required weekly reports. Her work ended in May 2024.
The minister and Harshita reached a proposed resolution before trial. The company, participating as an intervenor, did not agree, so the matter proceeded to a hearing.
Friedlander accepted that the company intended an independent-contractor arrangement and that Harshita expected employment. The hiring and promotion letters did not specify either status. Calling the position a manager did not resolve the question, and industry practice could not establish a shared intention where the worker was unfamiliar with it.
Both legal approaches pointed to employment
The parties had not established whether common law or Quebec civil law governed their relationship. The judge therefore considered both, reaching the same result under each.
Under the common-law approach, the central question was whether Harshita was conducting business on her own account. Relevant considerations included control, tools, delegation, financial risk and opportunity for profit. The parties’ intentions mattered but could not override the objective working relationship. Under Quebec civil law, the court examined direction and control and the existence of legal subordination.
Working remotely did not remove the company’s control over how the work was performed. It provided frequent, detailed instructions, selected the platforms, reviewed individual posts and controlled working hours. Harshita could not delegate her duties.
There were limits to those findings. After training, the company did not dictate her work location. Conflicting evidence about whether she could work for others was too unclear to carry material weight. The court also distinguished earlier television-industry cases involving workers with different skills, arrangements and shared intentions.
A laptop did not settle the tools question
Ownership of tools was neutral. Harshita supplied her laptop and home-workspace expenses, while the company supplied applications used to create content. The judge distinguished a content-creation tool such as Canva from a social media account to which finished work was delivered. There was insufficient evidence to classify every application used.
The company budgeted a set number of hours. Although some work occurred outside the usual schedule, there was little evidence of meaningful additional profit or financial risk. Doing well enough to secure a future project did not establish that this job was Harshita’s own business.
The decision turns on this working relationship. It does not classify all social media workers or all television-production workers as employees.



