Doreen Koch’s estate can pursue the real estate professionals involved in a failed sale of her Lumby, B.C., home for the legal bills she incurred defending her title. The B.C. Supreme Court also allowed a punitive damages claim against the listing agent to go forward. Justice Fowler ruled that both claims raised issues for trial. The ruling leaves liability and the amount of any damages to be decided.

In Wilson v Koch, the estate put the cost of defending the buyer’s lawsuit at approximately $244,000, against which it credited $48,000 already recovered from the buyer. The question was whether the balance could be claimed as a loss caused by the conduct of the agent, his brokerage and its manager.

A sale the homeowner opposed

Koch owned the property as a joint tenant with her son, Colin Jenkins. In July 2020, relying on an enduring power of attorney, Jenkins signed a contract to sell it to Matthew Wilson for $475,000. The estate alleges that Woody Kuroaka, the agent acting for Jenkins, had never seen the power of attorney when the contract was signed. It says Koch had agreed to neither the listing nor the sale.

Koch registered a caveat against the property stating that she was capable of signing for herself and wanted to keep her home. Wilson paid a $200,000 deposit. Jenkins died three days before the transaction was due to close, and it never completed. Wilson sued in 2021 seeking, among other things, an order compelling Koch to complete the sale. Koch brought a third-party claim against Kuroaka, Century 21 Executives Realty Ltd. and its manager, Steven Tate.

Wilson settled with the real estate professionals in December 2023. Koch died the following February, and Wilson discontinued his case against her in April 2024. Her estate later obtained permission to amend the third-party claim to seek its defence expenses. By the time the realtors asked for summary judgment, the parties agreed that the estate was pursuing defence expenses against all three and punitive damages against Kuroaka alone.

Why two claims in one court file mattered

The realtors argued that a party could recover litigation expenses only through a court’s costs order. Allowing the estate to recover its actual legal bill as damages, they argued, would bypass that system. The estate answered that it had incurred the expenses to protect Koch’s home against the buyer’s claim. It was seeking none of the money it had spent pursuing the realtors themselves.

Fowler pointed to a Supreme Court of Canada case involving lawyers who failed to secure a first-ranking mortgage for a client. The client could recover the cost of separate proceedings it had to bring to protect its priority. The distinction mattered here because the estate’s third-party claim, although it bore the same file number as Wilson’s lawsuit, could continue after he discontinued. A defendant can use a third-party notice to bring an independent claim arising from another party’s conduct.

The original third-party claim had sought protection against any liability Koch might have to Wilson. What remained after he withdrew was a claim that the realtors’ negligence and breaches of duty had caused Koch to incur defence expenses. Fowler concluded that those expenses could fall within the exception for separate proceedings. Whether the realtors breached any duty and what expenses the estate could prove remained open.

The claim against the listing agent

The realtors also argued that even if the estate’s account were accepted, the facts could not justify punitive damages. The estate said Kuroaka knew Koch well and visited her home regularly, yet listed and marketed it on her son’s instructions without checking his authority or telling her about the proposed sale. It alleged that after the brokerage learned of her objection, Kuroaka went to the house and demanded to see the power of attorney.

Fowler explained that B.C. law allows an estate to pursue punitive damages. Such an award can punish and deter exceptional misconduct where compensation alone would be insufficient. A trial court could find the alleged conduct toward a homeowner the agent knew personally sufficiently reprehensible to meet that test. Fowler dismissed the application for summary judgment and said the costs of the application should follow the outcome of the case.

Read the B.C. Supreme Court’s reasons, 2026 BCSC 2212.