
The Tax Court has refused to let an Ontario company’s principal officer represent it in that capacity in a GST appeal, finding no evidence that the corporation could not afford separate counsel and warning that parties remain responsible for authorities cited in AI-assisted filings.
In 2028604 Ontario Ltd. v. The King, 2026 TCC 187, Justice Perry Derksen dismissed the company’s motion on October 28, 2026. Amended reasons issued November 3 explain both the representation ruling and the court’s concerns about inaccurate citations.
The decision did not dismiss the underlying tax appeal or decide the correctness of the GST assessment. It addressed how the corporation could be represented as that long-running appeal moved toward trial.
A lawyer seeking to appear as a corporate officer
The company appealed its assessment in 2016. Its shareholder and principal officer, Nicholas Cutaia, is an Ontario lawyer and had relied on that professional status to act for the corporation.
The proceedings had encountered repeated delays, changes in representation and ineffective service addresses. A last-minute adjournment of the scheduled April 2025 trial led to a $2,000 costs order. Failure to attend a May 2026 status hearing resulted in a further $1,000 costs order and directions to clarify counsel’s current address.
At a September 2026 case-management conference, Cutaia confirmed he intended to testify. The judge raised the difficulty of acting as both advocate and witness. The company then sought permission for him to appear as its officer rather than as its lawyer.
Special circumstances required evidence
The court explained that a corporation in a general-procedure Tax Court appeal ordinarily must retain a lawyer. A 2024 statutory amendment allows the court, in special circumstances, to permit representation by a director, officer or employee.
Relevant considerations include financial impediments to retaining counsel, the proposed representative’s ability to prepare and present the case, the complexity of the issues, whether the representative would also be a witness and whether the litigation could proceed efficiently. The corporation bears the burden of establishing the circumstances supporting the exception.
Cutaia’s affidavit said nothing about the company’s financial capacity. The company argued that hiring counsel would be disproportionate to the amount at stake, but provided no evidence of the cost of the anticipated two-day trial.
The judge found that failure sufficient to dismiss the motion. A claim about the expense of counsel was not a substitute for evidence showing that the corporation could not afford separate representation.
Advocate-and-witness issue remained unresolved
The court also questioned whether a licensed lawyer could shed his professional status and duties simply by appearing under the corporate-officer exception.
The judge did not resolve that question because the motion already failed on the financial evidence. Nor did the order categorically prohibit Cutaia from continuing as counsel. It warned that, if he continued and sought to testify, the conflict between those roles could be raised by the Crown or addressed by the trial judge.
AI-assisted submissions still required checking
A separate concern arose from the company’s written arguments. They cited paragraphs of a 2017 decision, Masa Sushi Japanese Restaurant v. The Queen, for propositions those paragraphs did not support. The decision also predated the statutory provision on which the company relied. Another authority, described as Robson Enterprises, appeared without a citation.
After the court asked whether generative AI had been used, Cutaia confirmed on the company’s behalf that it had been part of the preparation process. The company apologized and submitted revised arguments. It removed the Robson Enterprises reference and one of the disputed paragraph references, but retained two unsupported references to the 2017 decision.
The judge concluded that Cutaia had not reviewed the cases cited in the original submissions and had not corrected those remaining references when given a further opportunity. The reasons warn that parties cannot transfer responsibility for their written arguments to generative AI.
The ruling did not impose a separate quantified AI penalty or make a professional-disciplinary order. Its decisive representation finding remained the company’s failure to establish the financial basis for the exception.
What the order required
The company’s motion was dismissed with costs in the cause, rather than a specified amount payable immediately. The order required it to file and serve a notice identifying counsel and an effective address for service by November 6. If Cutaia continued, he had to sign that notice as counsel.
The court also dismissed the Crown’s separate motion without costs because a motion seeking dismissal of the company’s motion was unnecessary; responding submissions would have sufficed. The reasons described a trial then scheduled to begin March 9, 2027. They do not establish whether the subsequent filing deadline was met.



