
After Halton Region disclosed more than 400,000 documents in a civil fraud action, an Ontario judge said the municipality had given too little detail about how it decided what to include. The judge also rejected defendant Nicolas Rewa’s request for every email he had sent, received or been copied on during 17 years at Halton. She proposed that the parties meet to narrow the search for additional records.
In Halton (Regional Municipality) v. Rewa et al, 2026 ONSC 6224, Regional Senior Justice E. Ria Tzimas considered whether Halton’s disclosure gave Rewa the records he needed to defend the action. Rewa said the municipality had produced thousands of irrelevant documents while leaving out thousands he considered relevant. Halton responded that the additional searches he sought would impose a disproportionate burden.
Halton told the court that its forensic accountant had collected more than 4.3 million records, including more than 1.8 million from the municipality. The collection drew on emails from people believed to have some connection to the alleged schemes, along with accounts payable, procurement and other records. Halton’s initial affidavit of documents listed 355,777 documents. Four supplementary affidavits brought disclosure above 400,000.
Those numbers did little to explain the selection process, the judge found. Halton pointed to records it had already produced from committees Rewa had identified, but did not explain why it had screened out other records in those categories. Without the criteria or search terms its team had used, the court could not tell whether the dispute was about relevance, the burden of further production, or both. Halton held the complete collection, which limited Rewa’s ability to pinpoint individual omissions.
Rewa’s narrower requests included committee records, bid reports, budgets and program change forms. Tzimas said his effort to connect those categories to particular allegations was a promising start. As a participant in the committees, however, he could explain which projects or periods mattered and how, for example, handwritten meeting notes or draft budgets could help prove or disprove a contested point.
The judge declined to order production of entire categories. She proposed that the parties identify search terms and limits tied to particular projects, people or dates. She offered a case conference if discussions stalled and said further submissions might be necessary. If Rewa had yet to undergo his first examination for discovery, she said, the exercise should come first, although it could also follow an initial examination.
Neither side received costs on the motion. Tzimas said she would order costs on further submissions if the parties could not agree and had to return before her. The ruling addressed document production. Halton still had to prove its allegations.



