The estate of an investor in a B.C. bed and breakfast filed its notice of appeal on time but served it 13 days late. What weighed more heavily with the judges in Jesani v Morgan was the next delay. After opposing counsel pointed out the missed deadline, the estate’s representative waited three and a half months to ask the court to extend it.

The dispute grew out of a bed and breakfast the Morgans ran on a property they bought in the Capital Regional District. Mirza Jesani and his wife invested in the venture. After the property sold, the Morgans won a trial judgment directing that they receive part of the sale proceeds held in trust. Alnoor Jesani, acting for Mirza Jesani’s estate, wanted to challenge that judgment.

He filed the notice on February 19 and served it on March 13. The court rules required both steps within 30 days of the trial ruling. The Morgans’ lawyer flagged the problem on March 16. Jesani applied to put the judgment on hold, but he did not file his application for more time until July 2.

No stay was in place during the delay. The estate’s lawyer had nevertheless declined to distribute the funds, and the Morgans faced further expense when Jesani sought to put off a costs hearing. Justice Horsman, writing for a unanimous panel of the B.C. Court of Appeal, said the judge who refused the extension could consider the financial hardship and uncertainty across the whole period.

The extension judge accepted that Jesani genuinely intended to appeal and appears to have accepted that the Morgans knew it. Those findings answered only part of the question. Jesani’s application offered no explanation for the wait after opposing counsel alerted him. Before the panel he pointed to his lawyer’s two-week holiday in June and the time needed to research the application. The panel said that account was unsworn, had never been put to the extension judge and did not reasonably explain the delay.

The panel also examined Jesani’s argument that the Morgans’ own accountant had confirmed the higher construction costs claimed by the estate. The accountant had used figures supplied by the other side to illustrate a different way to allocate the proceeds. He had never audited or verified those figures, which the trial judge had found unreliable.

The figures made a substantial difference to the division of the sale proceeds. The estate claimed more than $1.4 million in extra construction costs. The trial judge accepted $152,060 and fixed the Morgans’ 27 per cent share at $41,056. The estate also faulted the Morgans for failing to account for the inn’s profits. The trial judge had found that the estate’s representative had overseen the finances and that there was no evidence the Morgans received money beyond what the distribution already reflected. The panel found no basis to reopen that factual assessment on this application.

The judge who refused more time may have been mistaken about whether Jesani could file other appeal materials before getting the extension. The panel found that point made no difference to the result. It dismissed the request to change the extension ruling and the application to stay the trial judgment.

Read the B.C. Court of Appeal’s reasons, 2026 BCCA 448.