The Capital Markets Tribunal found Emerge Canada Inc. and two officers responsible for securities-law breaches, but cleared its independent review committee members.

In its November 9, 2026 reasons, 2026 ONCMT 35, the tribunal found that Emerge withdrew over $10 million from its funds, using much of it for its own and its affiliate’s operations.

Emerge put its interests ahead of the funds, breaching its duties of loyalty and care. Calling the debt a receivable did not prevent it from being a prohibited loan. Emerge failed to refer conflicts, maintain adequate conflict controls and keep proper records. Reliance on professionals did not establish that relevant compliance advice was obtained.

Lisa Langley breached her compliance duties; she and Desmond Alvares authorized, permitted or acquiesced in Emerge’s breaches. Alvares’s subordinate role did not excuse his participation.

Marie Rounding, Monique Hutchins and Bruce Friesen committed none of the alleged breaches. Emerge never identified and referred a conflict with a proposed response. The committee’s concerns and inquiries did not create that referral or general oversight duties.

Sanctions and costs remain unresolved.

A November 20 notice schedules a case management hearing for December 9, 2026, at 11:30 a.m., by videoconference.