
SoLVBL Solutions Inc. approved and published two misleading press releases. Its lawyer wrote them. In Chief Executive Office of the OSC v. Akbar, Ontario’s Divisional Court ruled that the Capital Markets Tribunal had placed too much weight on who authorized publication when it dismissed a securities fraud allegation against Ahmed Kaiser Akbar. The tribunal must reconsider that allegation.
The case arose from a technology licence SoLVBL granted to New Foundation Technologies Corp. in April 2021. Akbar acted as SoLVBL’s legal counsel and was New Foundation’s sole officer and director. In May, SoLVBL announced that it had won a competitive process. In June, it described its business partner as having customers in the United States, Europe and Asia. The tribunal found that there had been no competitive process and that New Foundation had no customers, employees or revenue.
Akbar drafted both releases for public distribution. SoLVBL issued them without changing the substance of the statements. The company later raised $4 million through two private placements. It used some of the proceeds to repay loans made directly or indirectly by Akbar and two other early investors.
The Ontario Securities Commission alleged that Akbar himself had perpetrated a fraud on investors. The tribunal reasoned that when he gave management his drafts, they were still internal documents. Management reviewed and approved the releases, and the tribunal found insufficient evidence that Akbar controlled the company or caused it to publish them. The commission’s chief executive officer appealed the dismissal of the fraud allegation. A separate ruling dismissing a misleading-statement allegation was outside the appeal.
Justice Nakatsuru, writing for a unanimous court, explained that a person’s conduct can contribute to a risk of financial loss even when someone else takes the final step. A contribution greater than trivial is enough to satisfy the causation requirement. By effectively requiring Akbar’s conduct to be the sole or primary cause, the tribunal set the bar too high. Akbar prepared the documents for release and sent them to management without warning that they contained false or misleading information.
Akbar argued that treating him as a contributing cause would let the commission change its case on appeal. It had accused him of committing fraud, he said, and could not switch to accusing him of helping the company commit it. The court agreed those would be different allegations, but found no switch. The commission had consistently alleged that Akbar used management’s trust to advance the scheme. It had never alleged that SoLVBL itself committed fraud.
The tribunal had also considered the act of drafting in isolation when it decided whether Akbar’s conduct related to securities. The releases actually reached the investing public. The court found that their statements were capable of influencing investors’ expectations.
The court also addressed Akbar’s concern about people with minor roles in drafting corporate documents. A draft that stays inside a company may never expose investors to harm. And even when a document concerns securities, the regulator must still establish the elements of the alleged wrongdoing against the individual. The decision to send Akbar’s case back turned on his own role and what happened to these two releases.
The commission asked the court to find fraud. That required a finding about whether Akbar knew his conduct could put others’ economic interests at risk. The tribunal had expressly left that question unanswered. The court directed that the same panel, if feasible, decide the allegation on the evidence it had already heard. It also ordered Akbar to pay the appellant $15,000 in agreed appeal costs.



