
Past audit waivers did not bind minority shareholder in buyout dispute
Royal Stainless Steel Tank & Truck must provide six years of audited statements. The judge left the disputed buyout and the company’s counterclaim for trial.
Section
Ontario Superior Court of Justice decisions and developments
51 stories
Royal Stainless Steel Tank & Truck must provide six years of audited statements. The judge left the disputed buyout and the company’s counterclaim for trial.

The tow truck was rear-ended on its way back from the restoration shop. A judge found the owner knew enough to sue within days, even as intermediaries discussed who would pay for…

A branch manager’s account of a loan call and records tracing borrowed money to the director’s personal expenses helped the judge resolve the signature dispute without a trial.

The father pursued a beverage business after leaving his teaching job. Even if its reported losses were genuine, the court found his skills could earn more in other work.

Ashawn Trench was ready for February trial dates that his co-accused’s lawyer could not make. The judge explained why the Crown could keep the two cases together.

The judge heard the request despite a gap in the son’s pleadings. His account of his father’s declining health fell short of the evidence needed to register a claim against the…

The defendants argued that their motion had succeeded because the plaintiffs had to explain the delay. The judge found that the choice of motion added expense and left the case on…

The defendant argued that fraud allegations and simplified procedure demanded quicker progress. The judge applied a five-year benchmark and also rejected dismissal over disputed…

Canada sought to rule out a declaration of ownership before the remedies trial. The judge found that evidence about reconciliation could still affect the outcome.

The Divisional Court found that a lawyer’s drafts could put investors at risk even though the company approved and published them. His knowledge remains for the tribunal to decide.

The tribunal mistook $362,880 in family invoices for professional care and overlooked an argument about how those expenses could qualify for coverage.

A letter of intent and years spent refurbishing the Woolwich inn gave its operators no right to stay after the owners ended their commercial lease.

A former stay-at-home parent found work as a home stager. The judge accepted those earnings for the interim order and left her capacity for full-time work open for trial.

The tenants said a filing problem kept a basement lease out of evidence. The judge examined what they had asked the board to do and whether the lease mattered to their utility…

A warning about possible dismissal applied to Liam Orlita’s current and future cases. The judge found the tribunal had imposed no sanction and could still address any unfairness.

The judge reduced both companies’ costs requests, finding that the work billed exceeded what the unsuccessful broker could reasonably expect to pay.

The minutes explained why the board hired counsel and what the proceedings could cost other owners. The court upheld a $5,000 tribunal costs award and ordered a further $10,000…

An Ontario judge held Dylan James Sliter liable under a personal guarantee and construction trust provisions, while leaving the claims against two defending parties untouched.

The national class-action compromise includes a 30-day loss protocol, legal fees and funding charges; it is not a trial finding of liability or $150 million in direct payouts.

The limitation period barred adding lenders to three guarantee claims, but the ruling did not dismiss the underlying lawsuits or finally resolve the agent's standing.