Second Cup and three other defendants must jointly pay $14,000 in costs to the plaintiffs in a Brampton franchise lawsuit after an unsuccessful attempt to take the case off the trial list. The defendants argued that their motion had achieved its purpose because the plaintiffs had to explain years of delay. Justice R. Chown found that the defendants had obtained neither the order they sought nor a dismissal of the action.

The November 12 costs ruling in VS International Inc. v. The Second Cup Ltd. concerns a lawsuit dating to 2014. The plaintiffs had signed franchise and sublease agreements to operate a Second Cup café in a Brampton plaza. They alleged that the franchisor, the landlord, the listing brokerage and its agent had misrepresented which other tenants would lease space there and draw customers. The court has yet to decide that claim.

Why the lawsuit stayed on the trial list

The plaintiffs’ new lawyer served a trial record in May 2024. The defendants argued that the plaintiffs had missed a court-ordered deadline and could not set the case down for trial. If the judge granted their motion, the plaintiffs would then have to show at a status hearing why the case should survive. At the first hearing in March 2026, Chown questioned why two hearings should cover much the same ground. The parties agreed to combine the issues, and the judge adjourned to May so the defendants could present evidence of how the delay had impaired their defence.

In his October 9 reasons, Chown explained that the parties had agreed in June 2021 on the dates in a new timetable, although they never obtained a court order formalizing it. That agreement shifted the focus to the delay that followed. The record did not explain 28 months of apparent inactivity between the last examination for discovery and service of the trial record. Even so, the plaintiffs had hired new counsel, answered their outstanding undertakings and were ready for trial. The judge also considered concerns about former employees and other possible witnesses who had died or might remember little. He found insufficient evidence that the delay had compromised the defendants’ ability to get a fair trial. The action could proceed.

Why the judge halved the costs

The defendants relied on an October 2024 settlement offer that would have taken the action off the trial list while allowing the plaintiffs to seek more time. Chown rejected their argument that holding a status hearing gave them the equivalent of that offer. The order taking the case off the list had never been made. The defendants could have sought a status hearing directly or moved to dismiss for delay. Their choice had added expense.

Chown acknowledged how close the plaintiffs had come to losing at the status hearing. Courts often leave plaintiffs to bear their own costs when they obtain extra time, he said, but defendants who oppose that relief also face a costs risk. Comparing the parties’ costs outlines, he accepted the plaintiffs’ $28,000 request for partial indemnity costs as reasonable. He awarded half that amount for the motion and status hearing together, all-inclusive and payable immediately.

Read the Ontario Superior Court’s costs endorsement on CanLII.