Xiao Lan Ren’s daughter said she had authority to sign for her mother’s company. Both women denied that the daughter could commit Ren personally to paying its debts. Ontario’s Superior Court of Justice found that Ren herself had knowingly agreed to an unlimited guarantee and ordered her to pay Toronto-Dominion Bank $51,541.96 on the company’s credit line and two credit cards, plus interest and $35,481.03 in costs.

In Toronto-Dominion Bank v. 1+2 Design Inc., the bank sought judgment against Ren, the sole director of 1+2 Design Inc., after the company stopped operating. The last payment was in August 2025. TD made a written demand the following month. The guarantee covered the company’s existing and future debts to the bank, including amounts it owed jointly with someone else.

Who agreed to the guarantee?

Ren knew about the corporate loan. She said her daughter, Yolanda Cai, handled the company’s day-to-day affairs and that she had little concern about corporate borrowing of less than $100,000. But Ren said in her affidavit that the signature on the personal guarantee was not hers. She said she was not fluent in English, had no legal advice and had never authorized anyone to give TD a personal guarantee on her behalf.

Cai testified that she had signed for her mother in her capacity as company director. She said her authority extended only to signing for the corporation. Ren argued that authenticating an electronic record could establish what the bank’s system recorded without establishing who physically used the device or whether the person had authority to bind her personally.

The bank’s branch manager, Jie Xu, gave the judge evidence about what happened before the documents were signed. Xu, who speaks Mandarin and English, said Ren and Cai were both on the call about the loan. Ren identified herself as the company’s sole owner and asked for credit. Xu told her she would have to provide an unlimited personal guarantee, a credit application and a personal financial statement. According to Xu, Ren confirmed that she understood and supplied a detailed list of her own assets and liabilities. The court also noted that her signature had been authenticated.

What the bank records showed

The bank traced more than $22,000 of the loan proceeds to property tax payments on two properties Ren owned. It also documented payments on her credit cards. Ren did not dispute those uses. Cai said she had made the payments for her mother. TD also pointed to Ren’s experience taking out mortgages. Ren acknowledged that borrowing history but maintained that giving a mortgage was different from guaranteeing corporate debts.

Justice C.F. de Sa heard from Ren and Cai and rejected their account of the guarantee. The judge accepted Xu’s account of the call, including Ren’s decision to supply her personal financial information after hearing the bank’s conditions. The use of the borrowed money for Ren’s own expenses also supported the bank’s position. Taken together, the records and testimony gave the judge enough evidence to resolve the dispute fairly without a trial.

The November 13 judgment sets out what Ren owes on each account. The credit line balance was $43,977.96, with annual interest at TD’s prime rate plus 3.85 percentage points. The two card balances were $2,509.86 at 19.99 per cent and $5,054.14 at 14.99 per cent. Prejudgment interest ran from January 6, 2026, and each contractual rate also applied after judgment. The separate costs award was on the full-indemnity basis provided for in the agreements.

Read the Ontario Superior Court’s reasons, 2026 ONSC 6409.