
A British Columbia judge has rejected a shareholder's attempt to use the oppression remedy to obtain a larger share of family company assets after his father's estate planning favoured his sister, while ordering the companies to produce financial statements.
In Fleischer v. Zoltan Elemer Fleischer Alter Ego Trust, 2026 BCSC 2203, Justice J. Hughes found that Ernest Fleischer had not established reasonable shareholder expectations that entitled him to corporate assets or the proceeds of property sales. His sincere belief about his intended inheritance was insufficient to establish a shared understanding among shareholders.
The November 16 ruling also rejected those expectations as objectively unreasonable in light of the companies' records, longstanding practices and the parents' later estate planning. Because the claim failed at the reasonable-expectations stage, the judge did not need to decide whether conduct was oppressive or unfairly prejudicial.
An inheritance dispute and a separate corporate claim
Ernest and his sister, Susanne Kierszenblat, held non-voting class B shares in Scott Road Trading & Auto Wrecking Ltd. and Fleischer Holdings Ltd. Their parents, Erika and Zoltan Fleischer, had controlled the companies, which held business and rental properties.
Ernest sought a distribution of excess cash and a purchase of his Fleischer Holdings shares at fair market value. He maintained that issuing class B shares to the children had been intended to give them the companies' growing value, while their parents retained income during their lives.
The defendants argued that the oppression claim sought, through another legal route, a redistribution already refused in earlier estate litigation.
In 2024, Justice Fitzpatrick dismissed Ernest's challenges to transfers to Susanne and an alter ego trust. That decision found no proven mutual wills agreement and concluded that Zoltan had capacity and deliberately arranged his affairs to favour Susanne, without undue influence. Hughes was bound by those factual findings in deciding the corporate application.
Both sides agreed that the remaining oppression claims were suitable for summary trial. Hughes was satisfied that the necessary facts could be found and that deciding them that way would not be unjust.
Missing records did not establish an estate freeze
The parties agreed that the class B shares had been issued as part of estate planning. But Hughes rejected the further inference that the arrangement was an estate freeze under which future growth would belong to that class.
Fleischer Holdings' articles included a schedule defining class C and preferred-share rights, but no schedule defining the class A and B rights. Ernest argued that a missing schedule must once have existed and suggested that it had been removed to frustrate his claim.
The judge would not infer destruction or withholding from estrangement and speculation. Ernest apparently had not explored the issue through discovery of a company representative. Parties on a summary trial had to marshal available evidence, rather than ask the court to fill gaps with unsupported inferences.
Even proof that a schedule once existed would not establish what it said. The known practice was that class A shares carried votes and received dividends, while class B shares did neither.
Hughes also declined to infer an estate freeze from particular transactions or restrictions on other share classes without qualified expert evidence about their intended effects. The demonstrated practice was to pay dividends on Susanne's class C share, not to distribute growth to class B holders.
Personal aspirations were not shared expectations
Ernest relied principally on statements he said his mother made decades earlier: that the class B holders would own the assets, receive notice and proceeds of major sales, and inherit after the class A shares dissolved on their parents' deaths.
There was no corroborating document for the central meeting he described. His account of later repetitions was vague. Susanne did not recall those promises and said their parents made decisions without seeking the children's approval.
Hughes distinguished an expectation shared within the shareholders' relationship from a personal aspiration arising from family ties. The class B shares lacked voting rights, there was no evidence of redemption rights or a shareholders' agreement, and dividends had never been paid on them. Nothing showed a change in their treatment since they were issued in 1974 and 1981.
Although Ernest subjectively believed he was entitled to the assets and proceeds, the evidence did not establish a shared shareholder expectation capable of supporting the remedy.
Assets, notice and sale proceeds
The judge separately found the asserted expectations unreasonable even allowing for informal governance within a family business.
Corporations own their assets separately from shareholders. Ernest could not reasonably expect his shares to make him the personal owner of company property. His suggestion of equal benefits also overlooked his earlier transfer of three Scott Road class B shares, leaving him with fewer than Susanne.
Nor did corporate law contemplate class A shares simply dissolving on the parents' deaths. Hughes rejected an attempt to reinterpret Ernest's affidavit as describing different, legally recognized transactions.
The claimed notice and sale-proceeds rights also conflicted with the evidence. Fleischer Holdings' articles expressly excluded non-voting shareholders from notices of meetings, and the parents had historically made major asset decisions without consulting the children.
No article or other contractual entitlement established a right to receive sale proceeds. Dividends were discretionary, and the articles permitted reserves. Hughes accepted that Fleischer Holdings retained proceeds for anticipated repairs and renovations to its rental property, consistently with prudent management and past practice.
Even if expectations of equal benefits might once have been reasonable, Ernest could not assume they would remain unchanged indefinitely. The documented estate planning and decades of corporate practice pointed otherwise. The judge also agreed that the claim sought to obtain substantially the result rejected in the estate ruling.
Financial statements still ordered
The companies conceded that Ernest reasonably expected audited financial statements and that this expectation had been breached. Hughes ordered audited statements, or another form agreed by the parties, for both companies.
The parties had separately agreed that Scott Road would be liquidated and wound up, with its funds addressed through that process. The reasons do not establish that liquidation or payment has occurred. Ernest abandoned his unjust enrichment claims against Scott Road; the other claims had been dismissed earlier or resolved by agreement.
The defendants were presumptively entitled to costs of the application and action as the substantially successful parties. No amount was fixed. If agreement proved impossible, a request to make further costs submissions had to be submitted within 30 days.
Read the full decision on CanLII.



