
Blair MacMillan had signed away the need for an auditor in several years at Royal Stainless Steel Tank & Truck Ltd. Those signatures did not carry forward. Ontario’s Superior Court of Justice ordered the company to provide its 10 per cent shareholder with audited financial statements for 2021 through 2026, even though the statements did not yet exist.
In MacMillan v. Royal Stainless Steel Tank & Truck Ltd., Justice K. Tranquilli drew a distinction between MacMillan’s rights as a shareholder and the buyout he seeks in his lawsuit. He could obtain the statements without first proving that Steven Crawford, Royal’s president and majority shareholder, had to buy his shares.
MacMillan resigned as vice-president of operations in August 2022. He says a shareholder agreement required Crawford to buy him out at fair market value when he left. The defendants say MacMillan never signed the draft agreement and dispute his claim that the parties treated it as binding. They also allege that his conduct caused Royal to fail a Transport Canada audit and lose licensing. Those allegations and the right to a buyout remain for trial.
The defendants pointed to resolutions in which MacMillan had waived the appointment of an auditor for 2010 through 2014, 2016 and 2018. Under Ontario’s Business Corporations Act, the judge explained, all shareholders must agree in writing to dispense with the audit requirement for the particular year. Royal offered no details showing the cost would be prohibitive, the statements would be of little use or MacMillan had acted in bad faith. The judge declined to extend the order to future years, leaving shareholders free to decide each year whether to waive the requirement.
MacMillan’s valuation expert also wanted existing records, including ledgers, corporate tax returns, payroll summaries and loan agreements. The defendants argued it would waste money to pursue a valuation before the court decided whether MacMillan was entitled to a buyout. But the court had not split the trial into stages, and the defendants had never asked for separate rounds of discovery. Tranquilli found that producing records Royal already had would help the court decide the issues without placing an undue burden on the company.
The defendants must also produce documents in their possession about the June 2022 Transport Canada audit. Because they claimed damages over the failed audit, those records mattered to their own counterclaim. And after Crawford confirmed that Royal had paid his legal expenses, the judge required answers about the fees. MacMillan alleges that using company money for Crawford’s fees while refusing to cover his own amounted to oppression. The November 13 ruling gives him access to evidence on that allegation and leaves its merits open. The court invited submissions on costs if the parties could not agree.



