
The operators of the historic Maryhill Inn in Woolwich, Ontario, hoped to buy the property they had spent years maintaining. When their commercial tenancy ended, they asked a judge to let them stay. In Penzendorfer v Denny, the Ontario Superior Court granted the owners immediate possession. The work the operators had done was part of their lease, and the owners had never agreed to sell.
Kimberley Denny and James Roche signed the lease with Julian and Darla Penzendorfer in August 2020. It required the operators to repair and maintain the inn. Rent began at $1,000 a month and rose to $2,500 by the end of the fixed term in April 2024. As the lease permitted, the operators stayed on as month-to-month tenants.
Denny and Roche said they had put considerable time and money into refurbishing the building. They stopped paying rent in November 2024 and said they put the money toward improvements instead. On September 24, 2025, the owners gave written notice ending the tenancy on October 31. The operators remained at the inn, prompting competing court applications.
The owners sought possession under Ontario’s Commercial Tenancies Act. The operators argued that the inn served as both their residence and their business, and that their dealings with the owners gave them rights beyond the lease. They asked to stay, to have the owners pay for needed repairs and to register a certificate of pending litigation against the property. The Landlord and Tenant Board had already determined that the residential tenancy legislation did not apply. Justice Latimer accepted that conclusion and found the evidence before the court also established a commercial tenancy.
A letter of intent signed before the lease and the parties’ later conversations showed that both sides had contemplated a sale. But the discussions depended on the owners deciding to sell and the operators being able to buy. The owners were not offering the property for sale. The judge found no agreement giving the operators an option to buy and no basis for a continuing interest in the land. Even accepting the operators’ account of their investment, the lease already required the maintenance they described.
Latimer found the written record sufficient to decide both applications without hearing witnesses. The judge declared the tenancy over as of October 31, 2025, ordered Denny and Roche to vacate immediately and gave the owners permission to issue a writ of possession. The operators’ application was dismissed. Costs remained open for the parties to settle or address in written submissions.
Read the Ontario Superior Court’s reasons in Penzendorfer v Denny, 2026 ONSC 6317.



