
An Ontario father who left a full-time teaching job to run a specialty soft drink business must pay $56,120.88 in retroactive child support. The business reported years of losses, but Justice J.R. McCarthy found that the father could have earned a teacher’s salary throughout the period when the child lived primarily with the mother.
In Tchappi v. Djemeu, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice used the salary grid in the father’s former collective agreement to calculate what he could have contributed. His imputed annual income rose from about $83,000 in 2018 to $120,000 from 2023. The arrears cover the period from the parents’ separation in April 2018 until they began sharing parenting time equally in February 2025.
What the father could earn
The father had taught full time for about seven years and had already started his beverage business while teaching. He told the court that workplace pressure and health problems had led him to seek a leave of absence. He said he intended to keep earning money as a supply teacher and had misunderstood his access to paid sick leave. He proposed $30,000 a year if the court decided to attribute income to him. The mother asked the court to use the salary he could have earned had he stayed.
A union representative had warned the father to check whether the school board would put him on its supply list before he resigned. The judge found he left without that assurance, never obtained a supply assignment and made little sustained effort to return to teaching. There was no record of a formal leave application or a request for modified duties. His teaching qualifications remained current, and nothing explained why he could not approach another board or a private school.
McCarthy found the evidence did not establish a health condition that prevented the father from earning income as a teacher. No medical report from the time of resignation said he was unable to teach. The judge gave little weight to a later opinion from a doctor who did not claim expertise in assessing employability. The father’s ability to manage, market and distribute his products also weighed in the court’s assessment of what he could do.
The business accounts presented a separate question. The father reported losses of more than $130,000 over six years. Yet the 2024 figures showed sales above $100,000 and wages above $53,000. McCarthy found that the business was concealing profits or that its profitability had been misrepresented. Even taking the losses at face value, the judge found that the father’s skills in food production, marketing and management could have earned him more working for another employer. The teaching salary grid gave the court an earnings benchmark supported by the evidence.
Arrears and shared parenting
McCarthy considered the hardship of a retroactive award alongside the financial burden the mother had carried. She had primary care for nearly seven years without reliable support. The judge found the father blameworthy for leaving secure employment and continuing to put his time into the business while the child went without consistent contributions from him.
The November 13 order set support for that period at $75,048 and credited $18,927.12 already paid. The father must pay $500 a month toward the remaining $56,120.88, starting January 15, 2027. Those instalments pay down the past debt. The judge found that the equal parenting arrangement was genuine, ordered no ongoing support and rejected the father’s own request for support under the shared-parenting provision in light of his imputed income.
The judge separately accepted $6,981.94 in swimming, dance and music expenses. The mother had covered most or all of those costs. The court found the lessons reasonable and in the child’s interests and said the father should pay his proportionate share based on his imputed income. The reasons do not put a dollar figure on that share.
The weekly and holiday schedules
The parents had agreed on equal parenting time, decision-making and travel before trial. The father wanted alternating full weeks to reduce trips and disruption. The mother favoured the existing rotation of two, three and two days. McCarthy kept that rotation because it was working, the parents lived close to one another and the child could maintain frequent contact with both.
The judge also accepted the mother’s Christmas proposal over the father’s request for a single exchange halfway through the school break. The parents would alternate Christmas Eve, exchange the child at 2 p.m. on Christmas Day and share the rest of the holiday equally. The parent without Christmas Eve would have New Year’s Eve. The judge found that a short local trip would allow the child to celebrate Christmas with both parents. The parties could return to court if they could not agree on costs, the terms of the formal order or how the arrears should be paid.



