
A British Columbia judge has revised a child's weekly parenting schedule while preserving joint decision-making, rejecting one parent's request for sole authority over education and counselling and allowing both parents to vacation in the United States without the other's consent on specified notice and communication terms.
In Ng v. Johnston, 2026 BCSC 2210, Justice Dion gave substantial weight to an updated parenting assessment after its author was cross-examined, while emphasizing that an expert report does not replace the court's own duty to decide the child's best interests.
The November 16 decision concerns competing applications by Stephanie Ng and Blake Johnston to change earlier parenting orders. The judge accepted a four-week rotation rather than Johnston's proposed equal-time arrangement, maintained existing school-break arrangements and directed that each parent bear their own costs because success was divided.
A schedule shaped by distance and school stage
The parents had previously followed a three-week rotation, with their son living primarily with Ng and spending much of his weekend time with Johnston. Johnston sought a 2-2-5-5 schedule that would produce equal parenting time. His proposal had been connected to a school-location request that he abandoned at the hearing.
The updated assessment, prepared under section 211 of the Family Law Act, recommended a four-week cycle. Johnston would have parenting time from Thursday at 5 p.m. to Saturday at 6 p.m. in weeks one and three, and from Thursday at 5 p.m. to Sunday at 6 p.m. in weeks two and four. This would give both parents some weekend time.
The expert, Dr. Michael Elterman, considered an equal split but was concerned about the distance between the parents' homes and the additional weekday travel. Johnston acknowledged that his proposed schedule would involve five commutes each week. The child's own comments also identified the long drive between homes.
Ng objected that missing school every Friday would mean losing 20 per cent of classroom instruction, before any additional absences. She also questioned whether time spent with a parent working from home justified that loss.
Elterman defended his recommendation under cross-examination. He considered the child's kindergarten stage significant and believed meaningful time with Johnston outweighed the missed Friday attendance at that stage. He was not unduly concerned that a working parent would sometimes leave the child playing independently, noting that parents do not spend every moment directly engaged with their children.
Dion accepted the recommendation in this child's circumstances. The ruling does not establish a general entitlement to miss school for parenting time. The judge agreed that arrangements should be reconsidered before grade one, after the parents had the benefit of a year of kindergarten, and suggested that they agree on lessons to make up missed Friday instruction.
The court retained responsibility for the decision
Under the Family Law Act, the child's best interests were the only governing consideration. The judge reviewed the importance of stability, relationships and the parents' ability to meet the child's needs.
Dion expressly recognized that a section 211 report is not binding. Its weight depends on the circumstances, and cross-examination or other evidence can lead a court to a different conclusion.
Here, Elterman had prepared two comprehensive reports. The updated assessment addressed the parents' complaints and the child's views, and the expert provided reasons for his recommendations when challenged. The judge found those recommendations reasonable in the circumstances and in the child's best interests.
The child had positive relationships with both parents. The persistent difficulty was their inability to communicate constructively and resolve parenting disagreements without court intervention.
Joint decisions and existing holiday arrangements remain
Ng sought sole parental responsibility for education and counselling decisions, relying partly on disagreements that had arisen between the parents. The school-location dispute had already been resolved, but their communication problems continued.
Dion accepted Elterman's concern that Ng's approach could minimize Johnston's role, contrary to the child's interests. The judge pointed to resistance to reasonable schedule adjustments and the tendency to send disagreements back to court. The parents shared decision-making responsibility; one parent's role did not take precedence over the other's.
The court therefore maintained joint parental responsibilities. It relied on the expert's balanced assessment of the current issues and both parent-child relationships, rather than treating conflict itself as a reason to give one parent sole control.
Johnston also sought a different summer schedule. Dion accepted the recommendation to maintain the existing arrangements for school breaks, including summer and Christmas, because they provided consistency and had been assessed against the child's interests. Later reconsideration remained possible.
The judge also endorsed using a parenting coordinator to help with activities, information sharing, special requests and potentially agreed changes to holiday arrangements. The reasons do not establish that a coordinator has since been appointed.
U.S. travel allowed with notice and contact
Ng opposed a broad U.S. travel permission and proposed limiting travel without consent to Washington State for no more than 72 hours. Dion found no basis for those geographic and time restrictions during either parent's own parenting time.
The judge allowed either parent to travel with the child to the United States for vacation without the other's consent, requiring at least three days' written notice. The reasons explain that necessary trip details include the destination, flight information where applicable, accommodation and proof of medical insurance.
For trips longer than 48 hours, the travelling parent must provide telephone or video communication with the other parent, followed by further contact every 48 hours or at other times the child requests. Dion rejected the more frequent mandatory contact proposed by Ng as unduly intrusive on the travelling parent's time.
The judge discussed travel beyond the United States but made no such order because neither parent requested it. The U.S. permission should not be read as authorization for other destinations.
Dion also accepted the recommendation that each parent avoid enrolling the child in activities falling on the other's parenting time, while warning that their inability to agree could limit valuable opportunities. The court's directions address how the parents should proceed; the reasons do not establish subsequent compliance or changes in the child's routine.
Read the full decision on CanLII.



