
Aurelio Baglione’s classic car had just been restored when another driver rear-ended the tow truck bringing it home. The towing company obtained an $8,166.51 repair estimate, and Baglione heard through intermediaries that it might pay. Ontario’s Superior Court of Justice has ruled that those discussions did not give him more time to add the company to his lawsuit.
In Baglione v. Spizziri, Justice M.S. Dunn found that Baglione discovered his claim against Classic Towing & Storage on the day of the June 20, 2023 collision or shortly afterward. By the time he sought to add it as a defendant, the two-year limitation period had expired. The November 13 ruling dealt only with the proposed claim against the towing company. The driver who struck the truck took no position on the motion.
Baglione knew about the collision the day it happened and learned within days that Classic Towing had transported his car. He never discussed the damage directly with the company. The owner of the restoration shop and a friend spoke to it on his behalf. Classic Towing obtained its estimate in July 2024. Baglione later obtained a substantially higher one. He said he learned only late that year that the company would not resolve the matter.
The issue was when a lawsuit became a legally appropriate way to recover his loss. A person can sometimes reasonably wait while someone with the expertise to fix a problem is still working on it. Dunn pointed to an earlier case in which a septic-system installer replaced a pump and assured the owners he could finish the repair. Here, the towing company knew how to move vehicles. Nothing indicated it could repair the car or that Baglione relied on it to do so. The discussions were about who would pay.
Dunn also rejected the argument that the talks amounted to an alternative dispute resolution process. A court can identify when a statutory process has run its course, the judge explained. Identifying the day settlement talks have finally failed is more difficult. Parties can keep negotiating even during a trial.
Dunn found the evidence sufficient to decide the timing question on the motion. Even if Baglione had not personally recognized that suing was an appropriate response, a reasonable person in his circumstances would have known when the accident occurred. The judge dismissed the request to add Classic Towing and fixed costs at $5,000, payable immediately.
Read the Ontario Superior Court’s reasons in Baglione v. Spizziri, 2026 ONSC 6382.



