
Two First Nations can continue seeking a declaration of ownership over 651 Crown-owned parcels on the Bruce Peninsula. In Saugeen First Nation v. The Attorney General of Canada, the Ontario Superior Court dismissed Canada’s motion to take that remedy off the table before the evidence is heard. Justice Matheson awarded neither land nor money.
The Chippewas of Saugeen First Nation and the Chippewas of Nawash Unceded First Nation, together the Saugeen Ojibway Nation, are seeking remedies for two historical breaches of the honour of the Crown. Of the 651 parcels, Canada owns 184 and Ontario owns the rest. The First Nations also claim $90 billion in compensation and damages. Canada’s motion addressed only the land.
The first phase of the case established that, after Treaty 45½ in 1836, the Crown failed to act diligently enough to protect the peninsula from settlers occupying the land, as it had promised. The second breach came during unsuccessful negotiations in August 1854. A Crown representative indicated the Crown would abandon its promise and recommended selling land without the First Nations’ agreement. The trial judge found those remarks had no significant effect on the decision to enter Treaty 72 that October.
Under Treaty 72, the First Nations retained specified lands and surrendered the rest of the peninsula for sale for their benefit. They accept the treaty’s validity. Their claim that the Crown breached a fiduciary duty failed at the liability trial. Those findings bind the parties in the remedies phase.
Canada, supported by Ontario, argued that a constructive trust was unavailable for the two breaches. Such a trust would recognize the First Nations’ beneficial ownership of land now held in the Crown’s name. Canada pointed to an earlier ruling in the same litigation that rejected a trust over roads and road allowances held by municipalities. Matheson agreed that the earlier ruling made the case for the land remedy difficult. It had not, however, decided the claim against Canada and Ontario.
The First Nations said they would present evidence about what would restore balance in their relationship with the Crown, including evidence about their own law and their relationship to the land. Matheson pointed to two recent Supreme Court of Canada rulings that gave courts latitude to fashion remedies that advance reconciliation. Neither had involved a constructive trust over land. The judge found compelling reasons the claim might ultimately fail, but Canada had to establish that failure was plain and obvious. Disputed facts and expert evidence still to come could matter to the outcome.
Ontario also argued that a declaration of entitlement would have no practical value because the First Nations could not enforce it in court. Matheson noted that provincial legislation expressly allows a declaration and that it could help the parties negotiate. The judge made no costs order on the motion. The parties may include the time they spent on it in later claims for costs.



