The Federal Court of Appeal has upheld the dismissal of four actions concerning whether Indian Reserve 175 was set apart for the Paul Cree Band rather than what is now the Fort McMurray #468 First Nation.

In Powder v. Canada, 2026 FCA 181, delivered October 27, a unanimous panel dismissed the appeals and awarded $4,500 in costs. The ruling leaves in place the Federal Court’s summary dismissal of the actions in 2024 FC 1912.

Historical claims faced a six-year deadline

The actions involved three groups of plaintiffs, identified in the reasons as the Powder, Malcolm and Dumais groups. Their requested remedies varied, with some seeking damages and the return of the reserve lands. The underlying allegation was that a 1921 order in council had set the reserve apart for the Paul Cree Band under Treaty 8.

The Powder and Malcolm appellants argued that the Crown breached its fiduciary duty when it later disregarded that band’s existence and treated the lands as reserved for Fort McMurray First Nation. Alberta’s limitations legislation preserved the application of an earlier statute to this kind of fiduciary-duty claim. Under that statute, the applicable period for breach of fiduciary duty or treaty was six years.

The Federal Court had identified events in the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s that would have made the Crown’s treatment of the reserve evident. The Powder and Malcolm appellants did not challenge those factual findings in their written arguments. Their earliest identified action began in 1997, after the limitation period had expired.

Trust and declaration arguments did not change the result

The appellants invoked a provision concerning breaches of trust to argue that no limitation period applied. The appeal court rejected that position, drawing on the distinction between the Crown’s trust-like obligations concerning reserve lands and an express trust. It also relied on Supreme Court authority recognizing that limitation periods can apply to fiduciary-duty claims concerning the administration of Indigenous property.

The Dumais group sought a declaration that the Paul Cree Band continued to exist as a band under Treaty 8, the Indian Act and common law. Their Indian Act argument depended on the reserve lands: they did not identify other lands set apart for the band, money held for it or a declaration by the Governor in Council.

The court observed that the requested declaration would affect Fort McMurray First Nation’s rights to the reserve. It questioned why such a declaration would escape the limitation period, but also identified a separate obstacle. The Federal Court had found that the evidence did not establish a Paul Cree Band separate and distinct from Fort McMurray First Nation. None of the appellants alleged a palpable and overriding factual error in their written arguments. The appeal court would not reweigh the evidence.

Costs could be increased after judgment

The Powder and Malcolm appellants separately challenged the Federal Court’s adjustment of its costs award. They argued that, once costs had been awarded, the court lacked power to increase them beyond the ordinary tariff basis.

The panel rejected that argument. Rule 403 of the Federal Courts Rules permits postjudgment directions concerning costs, including variation of a costs award and enhanced lump-sum costs. The court’s authority over that question was therefore not exhausted merely because it had already pronounced judgment.

Of the $4,500 awarded for the appeals, the Powder and Malcolm appellants must pay $3,000 and the Dumais appellants $1,500. The decision concerns these claims and their procedural record; it does not establish that every request for a declaration involving Indigenous rights is barred by a limitation period.