
Paddle Prairie Metis Settlement can appeal a tribunal’s decision to grant a resident a 10-year interest in 22 quarter sections of land for a proposed buffalo ranch. An Alberta appeal judge stayed the order that would have registered the interests in Ryan Bellerose’s name. The appeal will address whether the tribunal was entitled to award him the allotments itself after it set aside the settlement council’s refusal.
In Paddle Prairie Metis Settlement v Metis Settlements Appeal Tribunal, 2026 ABCA 362, Justice Michelle Crighton declined to reopen the tribunal’s finding that the council had acted unreasonably. The settlement needed permission to appeal on a question of law or jurisdiction. Two of its three proposed questions amounted to disagreement with how the tribunal had assessed the council’s reasons for turning Bellerose down.
Bellerose first applied for interests in the land in 2021 and gave the council a written business plan for his ranch. After he challenged the refusal, the tribunal directed the settlement to advertise the land again without adding conditions to the original posting. The settlement sought judicial review of that direction, then discontinued the proceeding. It took another six months to repost the land.
On the new application form, Bellerose described his intended use as “Ranch/Farm/Business”. The form asked for no further information. He assumed the council still had his business plan and would ask him for it if needed, although he acknowledged that the plan might need updating. The council refused his 2024 application on the basis that he had provided no evidence of his ability or commitment to carry out the project.
The tribunal found that the council had treated a business plan as a requirement without telling Bellerose. It had also overlooked his earlier application and years of effort to obtain the land. Although the council had listed other considerations under the settlement land policy, it had given little indication of how they affected its decision. Given the delays and the business plan Bellerose had supplied to the tribunal, it granted the interests and directed the land registry to register them within 60 days.
Crighton said the tribunal understood both the council’s broad discretion to allocate settlement land and its own responsibility to review the council’s reasons. The question she allowed to proceed concerned the remedy. The Metis Settlements Act gives the tribunal power to make decisions a settlement council could make. The settlement argued that the tribunal should have sent the application back because granting it was only one possible outcome. Crighton found it arguable whether, in exercising its powers, the tribunal had properly considered what was fair in the circumstances under the Act.
The stay defers registration pending the appeal. Without it, Crighton said, the settlement’s ability to deal with the land would be restricted for 10 years.



