
An Ontario condominium board could tell owners who had brought legal proceedings against their corporation when it reported on the dispute in its meeting minutes, the Divisional Court has ruled. The minutes named Jeff Clegg in describing his tribunal cases, the board’s response and the potential expense for other owners.
In Clegg v. Carleton Condo Corporation, 2026 ONSC 3094, a three-judge panel unanimously dismissed Clegg’s appeal and ordered him to pay Carleton Condominium Corporation No. 382 $10,000 in appeal costs. The ruling also upheld a separate $5,000 costs award that the Condominium Authority Tribunal had made against him.
Clegg, a unit owner, had brought several applications over access to the corporation’s records, the information they contained and what should have been redacted. In May 2024, for example, the board minutes identified him as the owner who had filed an application. They explained that the corporation would have a lawyer represent it and expected to incur significant legal fees regardless of the outcome. Later minutes reported how the proceedings ended.
Clegg argued that the board had to remove his name before sharing the minutes with other owners. He relied on a provision of Ontario’s Condominium Act that excludes records relating to specific units or owners from the records an owner is entitled to examine or copy. Writing for the panel, Justice Shore said the references concerned the litigation Clegg had started and its implications for the corporation. The tribunal had examined what the minutes actually said. The court agreed that the corporation had to disclose information about the dispute to owners and could identify the parties in that context.
A January 2025 update to owners raised a related question. With a revised periodic information certificate, the board told owners that a case had ended and estimated the legal costs for that and related matters at about $55,000. It said its budgeting meant it did not expect to raise fees or impose a special assessment to cover those costs. Clegg challenged both the timing of the certificate and the omission of the budget and insurance documents. Those documents had not changed since the previous certificate.
The appeal was limited to questions of law. The panel agreed that the decision to send an updated certificate was a matter of governance outside the tribunal’s jurisdiction. It also upheld the finding that the certificate adequately informed owners about the outcome and cost of the litigation.
Clegg also objected to the tribunal taking an earlier case into account when fixing costs. In December 2024, the tribunal had warned him that using records requests to pursue governance disputes or personal conflicts could expose him to higher costs in future. The panel held that the tribunal could consider that warning when assessing his conduct in the new case and deciding how much to award.



