An appellant who received three warnings that he was in the wrong court took no steps to put his case before the right one. In Lawyers’ Professional Indemnity Company v. Sochnyeva, the Court of Appeal for Ontario declined to transfer the case to the Divisional Court and ordered the appellant to pay $7,000 in costs.

Dmytro Sochnyev was appealing a November 2024 order striking his and Hanna Sochnyeva’s statements of defence. An associate judge of the Superior Court had made the order after the defendants breached court-ordered timetables, refused to attend examinations for discovery and failed to pay costs orders. Sochnyev alone appealed.

An order striking a defence is final. What determined the route of appeal here was who made the order. Under section 19(1)(c) of Ontario’s Courts of Justice Act, an appeal from a final order of an associate judge goes to the Divisional Court. At the hearing, Sochnyev’s counsel accepted that point and asked the appeal panel to transfer the case under section 110(1).

The panel identified three considerations in deciding whether to transfer a case. They were the strength of the proposed appeal, any undue prejudice the respondent would suffer from further delay, and how quickly the appellant acted after learning that jurisdiction was in dispute.

The last consideration carried particular weight. The insurer raised the problem when it received the notice of appeal in 2024. It raised it again at a status hearing on February 3, 2026, and at another on March 10. The panel found that Sochnyev had known of the problem from the outset and had taken no steps to put his appeal before the Divisional Court.

The panel also saw considerable strength in the insurer’s argument that the associate judge had acted within her discretion. That assessment counted against a transfer. The court quashed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction and declined counsel’s alternative request to make the order without prejudice to Sochnyev. The $7,000 costs award to the insurer was all inclusive.

Read the Court of Appeal’s reasons, 2026 ONCA 809.