When an Ottawa homeowner challenged his drywall contractor’s bill by text, he also put a number on what he thought he owed. Ontario’s Divisional Court has upheld a $17,218.94 judgment against him after finding that the trial judge could read those messages as repeated acknowledgments of the debt. Their timing kept the contractor’s claim within the two-year deadline to sue.

In Zandi v. Normar Drywall Inc., 2026 ONSC 6149, Justice K.A. Jensen dismissed Shaw Zandi’s appeal from a Small Claims Court judgment that also awarded interest and costs. Normar had worked on several projects associated with Zandi, including his Ottawa home. It sent its final invoice for work on the house on April 30, 2021. After Zandi complained about the work, Normar issued credits. The parties continued to disagree about deductions, tax and how earlier payments had been applied.

A January 2022 text began, “That’s not my bill.” Zandi relied on those words as a denial that he owed Normar money. But in the same message he said the bill should be between $5,000 and $8,000 and referred to a conversation outside his house. The trial judge rejected his explanation that he meant a different project. Jensen found that the trial judge was entitled to read the whole message as acknowledging an outstanding balance while challenging Normar’s calculation.

The dates mattered because Normar filed its claim on February 7, 2024. If Zandi had acknowledged the debt only in the January 18, 2022 text, more than two years would have passed. But the exchanges continued through April 29, 2022. The trial judge had considered them together and found that Zandi repeatedly acknowledged owing money as the parties worked through their differences over the account. Under section 13 of Ontario’s Limitations Act, an acknowledgment can restart the limitation period for a claim of this kind. It must be clear, but the debtor need not accept the creditor’s precise figure.

That finding allowed Jensen to leave a separate question open. The trial judge also concluded that Normar discovered its claim only when the discussions ended. Jensen saw merit in Zandi’s objection on that point. A creditor can have grounds to sue while negotiations are still underway. The acknowledgments independently supported the result, so the appeal did not turn on when Normar first discovered its claim.

Jensen also upheld the refusal to postpone the trial. Zandi’s representative wanted electronic copies of documents already provided to Zandi months earlier and available in the court file. He could have obtained them from his client and had them scanned. Normar was awarded its costs of the appeal, with the amount left for the parties to agree on or argue before the judge.

Source: Read the Divisional Court’s reasons on CanLII.