
The Federal Court has ordered Radio Mini-Page Inc. to reduce a roughly 110- to 112-metre communications tower in La Malbaie, Quebec, so the entire antenna system, including any antennas or accessories at its top, is no more than 44 metres high, rejecting the company’s argument that the structure escaped federal regulation because it was not transmitting signals.
In Canada (Innovation, Sciences et Développement économique) c. Radio Mini-Page Inc., 2026 CF 1384, issued November 12, 2026, Justice L. Saint-Fleur granted the industry minister a permanent injunction and awarded costs in the minister’s favour. The reasons do not specify a costs amount.
Municipal permission was not federal authorization
Radio Mini-Page had approached La Malbaie about a construction permit in 2022. The city told it a municipal permit was not required for the tower, while warning that approvals from other authorities could still be necessary.
The company nevertheless built the much taller replacement without first completing the required consultation process or obtaining federal approval. The existing authorized tower was limited to 35 metres. The new installation was far beyond the increase that could avoid the consultation requirement.
On June 30, 2023, the minister cancelled a licence for an antenna on the new tower after its applicant incorrectly declared that consultation was not required. New radio-licence applications for the tower and its antennas were also suspended.
The reasons describe an opportunity for consultation, local opposition including municipal resolutions and a petition signed by more than 1,000 residents, and the company’s resort to the minister’s dispute-resolution process.
On April 26, 2024, the minister refused to approve the replacement at its proposed height and required a reduction to a total antenna-system height of 44 metres or less within six months. Radio Mini-Page did not seek judicial review of that decision and did not comply. The minister applied for the court injunction in November 2024.
An unused tower can still be radio apparatus
The Radiocommunication Act prohibits installing, operating or possessing radio apparatus without the required authorization and compliance with its conditions. It also allows the Federal Court, on the minister’s application, to issue an injunction when satisfied that a relevant offence is occurring or is about to occur.
Radio Mini-Page argued that the structure was not radio apparatus because it had no attached equipment capable of radiocommunication and had never been used for that purpose. The company said no antenna remained on it from May 2025 onward.
The court rejected that argument. The statutory definition includes a device or combination of devices intended for, or capable of being used for, radiocommunication. The company’s own communications with the city described plans for wireless Internet, radio telephones, cellular networks and related applications, with equipment using an antenna at the top.
Its intended and possible use therefore brought the tower within the definition. Removing an antenna or not yet transmitting did not eliminate the need for approval. A contrary interpretation would leave construction outside the approval process until a tower was already operating, a result the court rejected.
The earlier decision could not simply be ignored
The company also relied on favourable municipal communications and comments it attributed to federal officials. It argued that the city had encouraged the project and that the minister had failed to account for that support.
The court found no evidence that the minister had approved the much taller tower or exempted it from the required process. Good intentions did not replace authorization. Nor did participation in consultation create a right to a favourable result.
Radio Mini-Page said the minister’s decision was unclear and that its owner had not been heard. The court noted that reasonableness and procedural-fairness objections could have been raised through judicial review. The unchallenged administrative decision remained enforceable and could not simply be disregarded.
The permanent injunction requires compliance with that decision and reduction to a maximum cumulative antenna-system height of 44 metres. It is a civil enforcement order, not a criminal sentence or an order to remove the tower entirely. The ruling reinforces that municipal requirements and federal antenna approvals are distinct, and that a tower’s intended use can matter even before it transmits.



