
A Nova Scotia judge has awarded a successful land-dispute defendant $40,024.49 in costs and disbursements, substantially reducing her request and cutting a $6,000 photocopying claim to $750 under the court's standard allowances.
In MacIntyre v. Gillis, 2026 NSSC 349, Justice Scott Campbell awarded Norma Woodill Gillis $30,000 in costs and $10,024.49 in tax-inclusive disbursements. The November 10 ruling followed an August trial decision in her favour in a dispute over land ownership.
Gillis had sought approximately $55,000 toward legal fees of $115,623.10, plus $18,408.23 in disbursements. Donald MacIntyre proposed costs of $18,250, calculated using the tariff and an allowance for trial days.
The court chose a lump sum because there was no reliable monetary value for the land dispute. It then examined the reasonableness of the fee request and assessed the separate expenses, accepting some despite missing supplier invoices while rejecting or reducing others.
No land value to anchor the tariff
The parties had sought a declaration about ownership, not damages. Neither had produced evidence of the disputed land's current value at trial or for the costs assessment.
Although costs are presumptively governed by Tariff A, Campbell found that trying to apply it without a meaningful baseline would be arbitrary. A lump-sum award was just and appropriate in the circumstances.
That did not mean the defendant's actual legal bill determined the result. Her accounts included work on an unsuccessful non-suit motion brought at the close of MacIntyre's case, for which Campbell had already awarded costs to MacIntyre.
The judge also noted that defence counsel's repetitive and collateral questioning had made the trial disproportionately long. He said this was not criticism of how counsel presented the case, but it was relevant to assessing the reasonable legal expenses toward which MacIntyre should contribute.
Settlement effort acknowledged, but its value uncertain
Gillis relied on a pre-trial offer to convey a portion of the disputed property to MacIntyre in exchange for $98,500. MacIntyre did not accept and responded with his own formal settlement offer.
Campbell considered Gillis's gesture toward settlement, but could not confidently assess its reasonableness without evidence of the land's value. The proposed transaction might have amounted to a sale at or near market value, rather than a meaningful compromise of the litigation.
The judge also rejected an argument that MacIntyre had merely acted as a conduit for a third party seeking additional property. That theory had been pursued at trial, but the evidence did not support a clear finding or inference to that effect.
Although there had been delays in bringing the case to trial, Campbell noted that Gillis had advanced a counterclaim herself. Taking the circumstances together, he found that $30,000 represented a substantial contribution to her reasonable legal expenses.
Copying charges must meet the standard allowance
The disbursement claim required a separate examination. After reviewing the parties' submissions, the court invited further argument about Practice Memorandum No. 10 and the apparent absence of third-party invoices. Counsel declined that invitation.
The memorandum standardizes common disbursement allowances, while permitting a party to seek a different amount supported by evidence. Campbell stressed that expenses must still be necessary and reasonable. A lawyer's bill showing a charge to the client does not, by itself, supply all the detail needed to make that assessment.
Gillis sought 40 cents per page for 15,000 photocopies, totalling $6,000. The presumptive allowance was 10 cents per page for half the copies charged to the client. Applying that formula produced $750: 7,500 copies at 10 cents each.
The court also reduced binding coils from $45.03 to $22.52 and rejected three unspecified copying-related entries because no details were provided. There was no evidence or submission supporting a departure from the standard allowances.
Trial experience supported some expenses
Missing invoices did not automatically defeat every claim. Campbell could assess some expenses from his knowledge of the trial.
He allowed a $4,830 survey-report charge, finding it reasonable after reviewing the report and its use at trial. He reduced a separate $4,332 expert charge to $2,500, based on the nature and duration of the expert's testimony.
A $462 witness claim was reduced to $100 because the witness had testified but supporting details were absent. Other unsupported process-server, witness and security charges were disallowed. The court accepted several filing, registry, discovery and witness expenses as necessary and reasonable.
The resulting disbursement award was $10,024.49, separate from the $30,000 costs award. The reasons determine what Gillis may recover from MacIntyre; they do not establish that those amounts have been paid.
Read the full decision on CanLII.



