The Ontario Court of Appeal has rejected OpenAI’s challenge to Ontario’s jurisdiction over a lawsuit brought by Canadian news organizations alleging copyright infringement, breach of contract and unjust enrichment. The decision allows the claims against six OpenAI entities to proceed in Ontario; it does not decide whether their use of news content was unlawful.

In Toronto Star Newspapers Limited v. OpenAI, Inc., 2026 ONCA 814, Justice B.W. Miller, writing for a unanimous panel, upheld the jurisdiction ruling and awarded the publishers $100,000 in agreed appeal costs. Justices Favreau and Rahman concurred in the November 13 decision. The costs award is not compensation for copyright infringement.

The plaintiffs include companies associated with the Toronto Star, Postmedia, The Globe and Mail, Canadian Press and CBC/Radio-Canada. They allege that OpenAI crawled and scraped their websites, used their content to train large language models and reproduced or used copyrighted material for commercial purposes. Those remain allegations.

The motion judge had granted the jurisdiction motion for four other named defendants. They were not the six appellants whose challenge the appeal court rejected.

Copyright’s territorial reach did not decide the court’s power to hear the claim

OpenAI argued that the court first had to decide whether the alleged conduct fell within the territorial reach of the Copyright Act. It relied on the Supreme Court of Canada’s SOCAN decision to argue for a broader inquiry into subject-matter jurisdiction.

The appeal court rejected that approach. Subject-matter jurisdiction concerns whether a court can hear the type of claim pleaded. Ontario’s Superior Court is a court of general jurisdiction, and the claims were of a kind it could decide. The separate question was whether Ontario had a sufficient connection to the out-of-province defendants and the dispute.

An argument that the pleaded conduct fell outside the Act’s territorial reach went to the merits and belonged in a motion to strike for failure to disclose a reasonable cause of action. Bringing that kind of motion would entail submitting to the court’s jurisdiction. The motion judge had not treated OpenAI’s jurisdiction challenge itself as voluntary submission, and therefore had not decided those merits arguments through that challenge.

The same distinction defeated OpenAI’s argument that copyright law was a complete code that displaced the contract and unjust-enrichment claims. The court did not decide whether that argument would ultimately succeed. It held that it was a substantive issue, not a basis for resolving this jurisdiction motion.

Several connections independently supported Ontario jurisdiction

The court approved the motion judge’s use of the Van Breda framework. Under that approach, a plaintiff must establish a good arguable case for a presumptive connecting factor, such as carrying on business in the province, a wrong committed there or a connected contract made there. The defendant can then try to show that the apparent connection is not sufficiently strong.

OpenAI argued that this framework did not fit copyright claims. The court disagreed, accepting the characterization of copyright infringement as essentially a statutory tort. Cases concerning the jurisdictional limits of administrative regulators did not displace that framework for private-law claims enforceable in a court.

The motion judge had identified several connections to Ontario, and the appeal court found no reviewable error in her assessment.

First, the record supported a good arguable case that operating entities carried on business in Ontario. Relevant activities included contractual arrangements, advertising and licensing products to customers directly or through third parties. The assessment considered the operations as a whole.

OpenAI emphasized its lack of physical presence. The court distinguished the standard for assuming jurisdiction from traditional jurisdiction based on a defendant’s presence. It found the existing authorities supported the conclusion on this record even without a physical presence. It did not accept an invitation to announce a broader new test based on active commercial participation, or hold that a merely accessible website would always suffice.

Second, the alleged copyright wrongs were sufficiently connected to Ontario. OpenAI argued that the pleadings had been expanded beyond reproduction and technological-protection claims, and that different activities, including scraping, training and alleged model infringement, needed separate analysis.

The court upheld the broad reading of the pleadings and the consideration of the evidentiary record. The allegations included using content to build and operate models and permitting Canadian users to infringe the publishers’ works. A jurisdictional connection did not have to be demonstrated for every alleged instance or form of infringement. The findings concerning material transmitted from or through Canada, or returned to Canada, attracted deference.

Third, the contract and unjust-enrichment claims supplied additional connections. The court upheld the finding that website terms could form enforceable agreements against commercial scrapers and that, on this record, the terms originated in Ontario. It also accepted a good arguable case that parent-company appellants controlled or profited from the operating companies’ alleged misconduct.

One sufficient connecting factor would have been enough. The court identified three, so even a successful challenge to the copyright connection would not have disposed of the jurisdiction issue.

OpenAI did not rebut the connections or establish a better forum

OpenAI also failed to show that the connections were too weak. The motion judge had examined the different entities’ activities individually. Repeating objections to factual findings about Ontario business and contracts did not establish the palpable and overriding error needed to overturn them.

The argument that most alleged copyright activity occurred outside Canada could potentially narrow the claims at trial. It did not eliminate jurisdiction over claims within the Act’s territorial reach.

Finally, OpenAI argued that the United States was a clearly more appropriate forum. The court upheld the motion judge’s discretionary refusal to stay the Ontario action. Witness location was neutral, Canadian and Ontario law favoured Ontario, and the American proceeding involved claims under American law. OpenAI had not provided evidence that a Canadian judgment would conflict with existing United States law.

The court also rejected the contention that the training activities could not be separated geographically and would produce inconsistent outcomes. The relevant concern was conflicting decisions on the particular facts, not the possibility that Canadian and American courts might answer novel legal questions differently under their own laws.

The appeal was dismissed. The publishers’ claims remain to be adjudicated on their merits.

Source: Toronto Star Newspapers Limited v. OpenAI, Inc., 2026 ONCA 814.