The Alberta Court of Appeal has refused to halt enforcement of a bankruptcy-related judgment over a liquor-store share transfer while an appeal proceeds. The amount remained to be finalized, and the ruling did not decide the appeal itself.

In Dhawan (Re), 2026 ABCA 368, Justice Karan M. Shaner dismissed Dinker Dhawan’s application to vary or cancel a provisional execution order. The November 17 decision leaves the trustee able to enforce the judgment once entered, despite the pending appeal.

The court found no serious issue demonstrated on the stay application, no established irreparable harm and a greater risk of prejudice to the trustee if assets were dissipated.

The value of the transferred shares remained open

The dispute concerns shares in Liquor Hour that Harmehak Dhawan transferred to her brother-in-law, Dinker. Cameron Okolita Inc., trustee in the bankruptcy of Harmehak’s husband, Gautam, had obtained judgments against her and later received authority to pursue proceedings in her bankruptcy.

A Court of King’s Bench judge found that the share transfer was for less than its value under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act. Harmehak and Dinker maintained that he had paid $300,000, largely from cash savings kept at home. The judge rejected their evidence: Dinker’s employment earnings fell short of the claimed savings, and his explanation changed when challenged. The judge found that nothing had been paid and that they intended to defraud, defeat or delay the trustee as a judgment creditor.

The judge gave Dinker 45 days to provide evidence of the shares’ value. Failing that, the trustee could enter judgment for $300,000. A valuation hearing was scheduled for November 26, 2026. The figure was therefore not treated by the appeal court as a finalized judgment amount.

The lower court also authorized provisional execution. Although section 195 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act ordinarily stays an appealed order or judgment, that protection does not apply where provisional execution has been ordered. Shaner treated the application as a request to cancel that order, applying the familiar stay factors within the statute’s broader consideration of relative prejudice and the interests of justice.

The appeal arguments did not justify a stay

Dinker argued that the lower judge had reversed the burden of proof and ignored evidence supporting payment, including a bank draft, receipts and records concerning the business’s ownership and licensing.

Shaner found that these arguments largely challenged factual conclusions. The judge had been entitled to assess all the evidence and draw inferences about payment and intent. Those findings would attract appellate deference and require a palpable and overriding error to overturn.

Dinker also challenged the $300,000 valuation and provisional execution without proof of the shares’ actual value. Shaner noted that he and Harmehak had themselves asserted a purchase at that price. More importantly, the lower judge had allowed further valuation evidence before finalizing the amount.

While expressly declining to decide the appeal’s merits, Shaner found that the arguments and evidence presented on this application did not meet even the low threshold of a serious issue to be argued.

Financial and business concerns did not establish irreparable harm

Dinker said enforcement could cost him ownership and control of Liquor Hour and affect its licensing, banking and commercial relationships. Shaner found that scenario speculative. A requirement to pay money did not necessarily mean losing the shares, and Dinker had not shown that other assets or funds were unavailable. The record indicated that he remained employed full-time.

The trustee also supplied evidence that, as of October 16, there was no registered liquor licence for Liquor Hour on the regulator’s website and the store was not open. The ruling did not establish a later operating status.

On the balance of convenience, the lower judge’s finding that Dinker was dealing with assets in a way likely to hinder enforcement weighed strongly against relief. If Dinker succeeded on appeal, he could recover the value paid through enforcement. If he lost after dissipating assets, the trustee would face the greater harm.

Shaner noted that there was no suggestion the appeal would not be pursued diligently. Even so, the evidence did not establish a compelling reason to interfere with provisional execution. The stay application was dismissed, leaving the appeal and final valuation to be determined.

Source: Dhawan (Re), 2026 ABCA 368.