
The Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission found that a small Internet provider's challenge to telecom complaint fees raised issues requiring a broader examination, but did not grant immediate relief from the disputed fee system.
In Telecom Decision CRTC 2026-30, InnSys Inc. – Application regarding the participation of small telecommunications service providers in the Commission for Complaints for Telecom-television Services Inc., issued February 13, 2026, the commission launched a consultation on complaint-based fees and the mechanism for disputing them.
Other parts of InnSys's application were either already addressed or outside the decision's scope. The commission expressly declined to waive the company's obligation to promote the complaints body under its participation agreement.
Non-payment led to a regulatory challenge
The Commission for Complaints for Telecom-television Services, known as the CCTS, is an independent, not-for-profit body that helps resolve disputes between customers and telecommunications and television providers. Its complaint-resolution services are free to customers, while telecommunications providers must participate and contribute funding.
The CCTS ended InnSys's participation in 2023 after the company failed to pay annual and complaint-based fees. The decision described InnSys as apparently non-compliant with the participation requirement. InnSys said it had withheld payment to protest a structure it considered unfair to small providers.
In its December 2024 application, InnSys sought a clear fee-dispute process, a streamlined complaints procedure, a review of complaint-based charges and reconsideration of promotional requirements.
Equal charges could have unequal effects
InnSys argued that it faced charges for complaints it considered baseless or for which it was not at fault. The CCTS responded that complaint fees recover costs regardless of a provider's size or fault, and increase as a complaint advances through the resolution process.
That design was intended to encourage early resolution. The CCTS also said it had removed initial sign-up fees and stopped charging for complaints later found to fall outside its mandate.
The commission found that data supplied by the CCTS showed complaints against small providers were typically resolved later in the process. That resulted in a higher average fee per complaint than large providers paid. The commission said limited resources and staffing might explain the difference.
It concluded that the fee structure could create a barrier for some small providers and impede efficient resolution of customer complaints. Further information was needed to determine whether mitigation was warranted.
The resulting Telecom Notice of Consultation CRTC 2026-31 therefore examined the effect of complaint fees on small providers and whether a more effective fee-dispute mechanism was needed. Its concerns were preliminary views, not a final determination that the system was unlawful.
Correcting invoices was not the whole issue
The CCTS told the commission that incorrectly charged fees could be disputed and corrected. Providers also were not charged for complaints later determined to be outside its mandate. Those safeguards did not resolve the broader disagreement over fees and the procedures through which they arose.
The commission acknowledged that it had not historically reviewed the independent body's operational practices. It nevertheless considered that a fee-dispute mechanism could improve complaint resolution and reduce referrals concerning providers' non-compliance with participation requirements.
The ruling also dealt with InnSys's other objections. The commission found that the CCTS had addressed concerns about its complaints process through changes launched in May 2023 after extensive consultation, in which InnSys could have participated.
The commission also said InnSys's concerns about interim wholesale Internet access rates had already been addressed in an earlier regulatory policy.
Publicizing the end of InnSys's participation was consistent with the commission's expectations. However, the regulator encouraged the CCTS to add context about the alleged non-compliance and related proceedings, including the forthcoming fee consultation.
Later proceedings kept the review focused
In a March 11 procedural ruling, the commission extended the consultation deadlines but rejected TELUS's request to cancel the proceeding in favour of a comprehensive CCTS review. It said examining these discrete issues separately was more efficient and in the public interest.
A separate August 24 ruling on customer awareness rejected a request to suspend that proceeding pending a comprehensive review. The commission said findings from work on customer awareness, complaint fees and consumer-code harmonization could inform a later overall review.
On October 23, Telecom Order CRTC 2026-279 awarded the Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project $14,406.08 for participating in the fee consultation. That order addressed participation costs, not the final design of CCTS fees.
The February decision's practical result was further scrutiny of the fee structure and dispute process. It did not replace them or excuse InnSys from its promotional obligations.
Source: Read the CRTC’s decision.



