A B.C. judge preserved a hotel’s trademark licence and ordered the handover of digital-account access needed for its receivership sale, while expressly protecting ownership of the licensed marks themselves.

In Fox Island Development Ltd. v. Kensington Union Bay Properties Nominee Ltd., 2026 BCSC 441, Justice Fitzpatrick also awarded solicitor-and-client costs against the company that had tried to terminate the licence. She found that its controller’s actions were designed to interfere with the imminent sale of Richmond’s Versante Hotel.

The February 24 ruling distinguished access to assets needed to operate the hotel from ownership of the trademarks. The substantive relief had been negotiated and was unopposed by the hearing; the contested question was who should bear the costs of resolving the disruption.

A licence notice threatened the sale

Deloitte Restructuring Inc. had been appointed receiver in March 2025. An amended receivership order stayed proceedings against the debtor companies and their assets unless the court approved them or the receiver consented in writing.

The hotel used its name under a 2021 trademark agreement with 1036524 B.C. Ltd., referred to in the reasons as 103 BC. The agreement included a clause permitting termination if Hotel Versante Ltd. became insolvent or a receiving order was filed against it.

After an earlier buyer failed to close, the receiver moved forward with a court-approved backup sale to an affiliate of the secured lenders. Its agreement covered substantially all the debtors’ interests in the hotel, including intellectual property. That definition extended to social-media accounts, software, internet addresses, domain names and licences used by the debtors. The purchaser also exercised its right to require assignment of the hotel’s interest in the trademark agreement.

On February 4, Michael Ching sent the receiver a termination notice on 103 BC’s behalf, asserting that the licence would end on March 31. The receiver responded that the notice violated the receivership stay.

The disruption was practical as well as legal. The hotel’s branding depended on its name, while digital accounts supported reservations, room inventory, booking channels, guest communications, marketing and payment processing. Without control of those accounts, the receiver could neither ensure uninterrupted operations nor deliver what the purchaser had agreed to buy.

Digital access was not trademark ownership

The receiver sought administrative credentials from Michael Ching and Linda Ching. The reasons record that Linda Ching began cooperating to transfer information after resigning as the hotel’s marketing director. Michael Ching, however, said access to accounts he controlled would be provided only after the trademark was removed from the hotel in accordance with the termination notice.

New insolvency counsel for 103 BC eventually facilitated a resolution. A crucial addition clarified that the order would neither transfer the licensed marks themselves nor compel their transfer. It also preserved the trademark agreement’s terms and the parties’ rights, subject to further court orders.

With that protection, the court declared the termination notice contrary to the stay and of no force or effect. The trademark agreement remained in force, preserving the purchaser’s ability to use the hotel’s name after closing.

The court separately declared the digital-account login credentials, passwords and usernames to be assets of Hotel Versante Ltd. covered by the purchase agreement. Michael Ching, Linda Ching, 103 BC and anyone else controlling the accounts were ordered to deliver access so the receiver could assume full administrative control and transfer it to the purchaser. The signed order made that obligation ongoing, including updated, reset or replacement credentials.

The distinction matters to the result: the order preserved the operating licence and compelled delivery of digital assets included in this particular sale. It did not award the purchaser ownership of the underlying licensed trademarks.

Why costs remained contested

Counsel for 103 BC argued that much of the relief had been agreed after the application was filed, suggesting a formal order was unnecessary. The judge accepted the receiver’s position that a court order was needed to remove uncertainty, including over accounts that might not yet have been identified.

The dispute had already delayed the planned closing twice. The judge found that Michael Ching knew the sale was imminent and had deliberately tried to obstruct it, personally and on 103 BC’s behalf.

She rejected as fanciful the suggestion that he needed to retain the Google Workspace account because he might someday establish another hotel with the same name. Although she acknowledged new counsel’s role in reaching agreement, she concluded that the receiver and lenders had acted appropriately to resolve an issue that prevented the sale from proceeding.

The costs order was against 103 BC alone. Neither the receiver nor the lenders sought a costs award against Michael or Linda Ching personally.

The receiver and lenders were awarded solicitor-and-client costs for work on this particular issue from February 9 through February 24. Work on other matters during that period was excluded, and the amounts were to be assessed by the registrar. The reasons did not set a dollar award.

A signed receiver’s certificate dated February 25 subsequently certified that the purchase agreement’s conditions had been satisfied or waived and that the sale would be completed upon filing the certificate. It did not report the amount of the costs award or establish that those costs had been paid.

Source: Fox Island Development Ltd. v. Kensington Union Bay Properties Nominee Ltd., 2026 BCSC 441.