The Federal Court of Appeal has upheld two CRTC decisions preventing Rogers from changing the packaging and channel placement of Corus services during a carriage dispute, finding that the regulatory standstill freezes distribution conditions rather than merely extending contractual rights.

In Rogers Communications Inc. v. Corus Entertainment Inc., 2026 FCA 49, released March 5, Justice Wyman Webb, with Justices Gerald Heckman and Monica Biringer concurring, dismissed both appeals with costs.

Contractual permission did not settle the regulatory question

The dispute concerned Slice, Flavour Network, formerly Food Network Canada, and Home Network, formerly HGTV Canada. Rogers distributed the services under affiliation agreements for eastern and western Canada. The CRTC treated September 8, 2023 as the operative standstill date, which neither party challenged.

In November 2024, the regulator first refused Rogers’ proposal to remove Slice from preassembled packages and offer it separately. A second decision required continued distribution of all three services at existing rates and conditions, including packaging and channel placement. Rogers argued that changes in content and branding following its related company’s acquisition of programming rights meant the standstill should no longer apply.

An Ontario court had separately concluded that Rogers’ eastern agreement permitted repackaging, subject to its contractual provisos. That did not answer the appeal. The Ontario decision expressly left the regulatory standstill to the CRTC. The issue was whether regulation suspended an otherwise available contractual right.

Preserving actual distribution conditions

The court rejected Rogers’ reading that the standstill preserved the contract together with every power to change distribution terms. Such a reading would let a distributor exercise a contractual termination right during a dispute, defeating the status quo. Rogers itself had continued carrying Corus programming after the agreements’ stated expiry at the end of 2024 because of CRTC intervention.

The regulation requires distribution at the same rates and on the same conditions as before the dispute. Just as a contractual rate-adjustment power cannot defeat the rate freeze, a repackaging power cannot defeat the freeze on packaging. Earlier CRTC policy statements were not uniformly clear on this distinction, and the previous TVA Group decision did not establish that every contractual change remained permissible.

The broader scheme supported this interpretation. Mediation and CRTC determination provide routes to resolve a dispute; the rule is not necessarily indefinite. Maintaining existing arrangements also avoids disruption to subscribers if a packaging change later has to be reversed. The Broadcasting Act expressly addresses reasonable packaging terms and gives the CRTC broad dispute-resolution powers.

Programming changes raised factual issues

Rogers argued that Corus had materially changed the three services and that the standstill must operate even-handedly. The CRTC found that they retained the same licences, themes and overall focus despite replacement programs. Those were factual findings. The statutory appeal route permitted questions of law or jurisdiction, not factual disagreement or mixed questions without an identifiable legal error.

Nor had Rogers argued before the regulator that its own proposed packaging or placement changes were immaterial. Its argument about Corus’ contractual obligation to supply particular content would require contract interpretation, ordinarily a mixed question of fact and law, rather than establish an appealable legal error.

For channel placement, Rogers relied on a regulation requiring 60 days’ notice before realignment. The court said that provision prohibits changes without notice; it does not confer an unconditional right to realign. The standstill can impose an additional restriction. Rogers also should have presented that argument to the CRTC.

The judgment upheld the two regulatory decisions; it did not determine the ultimate commercial terms between the parties or report a later resolution of their carriage dispute. The standstill described in the reasons was tied to the dispute and its resolution, not a permanent obligation to distribute those channels.