A Prince Edward Island judge has refused a former stepparent permission to seek a parenting order, finding that his evidence of helping with a child’s daily routines did not establish that he had assumed, or intended to assume, a parental role.

In N.A.J.G. v. D.M.G.(H), 2026 PESC 12, Justice Sophie MacDonald held that the applicant first had to satisfy the status requirement in section 39 of the province’s Children’s Law Act. Because he did not meet that threshold, the court did not proceed to decide whether granting leave would be in the child’s best interests.

The April 10 decision concerned only his proposed application regarding his former partner’s child. It did not determine parenting arrangements for the parties’ shared biological child, who was the subject of a separate interim consent order.

A relationship was not enough on its own

The applicant argued that he had acted as a parent during the relationship and continued spending time with the child after separation. He relied on the child’s best interests and earlier decisions identifying factors relevant to granting leave.

The mother disputed his description of the relationship. She argued that the court first had to decide whether he stood in the place of a parent, rather than begin with a general assessment of the benefits of contact.

Section 39 allows a person other than a parent who stands, or intends to stand, in the place of a parent to apply for parenting time or decision-making responsibility, but only with the court’s permission. MacDonald treated those requirements as sequential: establish the qualifying parental role or intention, then consider whether leave should be granted in the child’s best interests.

That distinction kept the hearing focused. The question was not simply whether the applicant knew the child, cared about the child or wanted a continuing relationship.

Intention had to be shown through the relationship

Drawing on the Supreme Court of Canada’s guidance in Chartier v. Chartier, the judge emphasized an objective assessment of the relationship as a whole. Relevant factors can include financial provision according to means, discipline, participation in the extended family, representations that the adult is responsible as a parent, and the child’s relationship with a biological parent.

Intention may be inferred from conduct, rather than expressed formally. But neither a positive relationship nor an assertion that an adult wants to parent is automatically sufficient. The court also considered PEI decisions distinguishing involvement in a functioning household from a settled intention to take on parental responsibility.

Even the applicant’s account fell short

The applicant’s description of his role before separation was concentrated in one affidavit paragraph. He said he prepared meals, helped with homework, cared for the child when the mother was absent, bought necessities and toys, assisted with school and activity transportation, and helped with morning and bedtime routines.

The judge found important gaps in the evidence about the nature of the relationship. These included whether the applicant disciplined the child, acted as a parent with school or health professionals, represented himself as the child’s parent, or treated the child as a family member in the relevant extended-family setting. Much of the evidence instead concerned events after separation.

Although the mother disputed his account, MacDonald said she did not need to resolve that credibility conflict. Even taking his description at face value, it did not establish the necessary settled intention and supporting actions.

Adults in many kinds of relationships assist children with daily tasks, the judge explained. Those contributions do not, without more, put every caregiver into a parental role. The decision applied that distinction to this record rather than ruling that stepparents can never obtain parenting orders.

Leave refused, costs amount left open

The court dismissed the application for leave. It also directed that the court-file heading be corrected to reflect the mother’s proper initials, D.M.H.

The mother was awarded costs as the successful party, but the reasons did not set an amount. The parties were encouraged to agree through counsel; otherwise, the decision established a written-submissions timetable. It does not establish the outcome of any later costs determination.

Source: N.A.J.G. v. D.M.G.(H), 2026 PESC 12.