A Manitoba driver failed to overturn a three-month roadside licence suspension after the Court of King’s Bench rejected her attempt to add later medical evidence and upheld the administrative review decision.

In Hosco v. Manitoba (Registrar of Motor Vehicles), 2026 MBKB 51, delivered April 15, Justice Lanchbery also dismissed Sharon Hosco’s claims under sections 7 and 10(b) of the Charter. Each party was ordered to bear its own costs.

The decision concerned an administrative suspension, not a criminal conviction for refusing a breath demand. Its central evidentiary distinction was between a medical explanation supporting inability to provide a sample at the roadside and evidence about a condition assessed months later.

Twelve attempts and an unsuccessful review

An RCMP officer stopped Hosco for speeding in November 2024 and demanded a breath sample using an approved screening device available in the police vehicle. Twelve attempts produced no reading, despite demonstrations and a changed mouthpiece.

Hosco said she was physically unable to complete the test. The officer issued a speeding ticket, vehicle impoundment notice and immediate three-month driving prohibition.

With legal assistance, Hosco sought administrative review. Her materials included an affidavit, written submissions and a physician’s letter. The reviewing officer confirmed the suspension, finding that the information did not establish a reasonable excuse for failing to provide a proper sample.

Hosco then sought judicial review. She challenged the adequacy of the reasons, raised Charter arguments and sought to introduce further medical material based on an assessment in July 2025.

Later evidence did not establish the earlier inability

The court applied reasonableness review to the registrar’s decision. It rejected the new-evidence request both because the relief had not been pleaded and because the material did not establish inability to provide a sample when the November demand was made.

Lanchbery emphasized that judicial review examines a decision already made. Allowing a new evidentiary case could turn that limited review into a fresh hearing. The later assessment did not cure the lack of sufficient medical support for the claimed inability on the relevant date.

The court found the reviewing officer’s decision reasonable on the record then available. It also rejected the allegation that reasons had not been supplied: the officer had provided written reasons explaining why the supporting information did not establish a reasonable excuse.

The result was not a finding that a genuine medical inability can never excuse failure to provide a breath sample. It turned on what the evidence established about this driver’s ability at the time of the demand.

Charter claims dismissed on this record

Hosco argued that the suspension and related consequences engaged section 7, which protects life, liberty and security of the person. Applying Manitoba authorities, the court held that the administrative consequences in this case did not engage those protections. It acknowledged the practical difficulty a driving suspension can create for someone living outside a major city.

Her right-to-counsel argument focused on the 40 minutes between the final unsuccessful breath attempt and her friend’s arrival to drive her home. She argued that legal advice might have helped her obtain alternative evidence.

The court ultimately found that this waiting period was not detention: Hosco could no longer drive, but was legally free to leave and was waiting for transportation. It dismissed the section 10(b) claim along with the judicial-review application and fresh-evidence request.

A practical issue remained outside that dismissal. Counsel for the registrar and Manitoba agreed to examine how the later medical findings could affect Hosco’s use of an ignition-interlock device. The judgment records that agreement, not a subsequent exemption or resolution.