
Newfoundland and Labrador’s Court of Appeal allowed a parent to challenge a continuous-custody order after missing the filing deadline, finding that fairness required the appeal to proceed alongside a closely connected, timely appeal concerning another child.
In S.R. v. Newfoundland and Labrador (Manager of Child and Youth Services), 2026 NLCA 13, Justice F.P. O’Brien also struck a separate appeal concerning interim access. That appeal had been overtaken by a subsequent continuous-custody order. The April 24 ruling addressed which appeals could proceed, without deciding whether the underlying child-protection findings were correct.
A publication ban protects the identities of the children, their biological parents, relatives and foster families. The parent is identified only by the initials used in the judgment.
Two connected custody decisions
The Supreme Court had made separate continuous-custody orders in July and September 2025. S.R. appealed the September order within the required 30 days, but missed the deadline for the July order. About two weeks after that deadline, she applied for an extension and supplied a draft notice of appeal.
The appeal court considered whether she had genuinely intended to appeal within the filing period, whether there was a reasonable explanation for the delay, the potential merits, and any exceptional or special circumstances affecting the fairness of an extension. Those factors were neither exhaustive nor requirements that all had to be satisfied in every case.
S.R. explained that a Legal Aid lawyer had represented her at the custody hearing. After learning of the decision by telephone, she wanted to appeal and tried to establish whether Legal Aid would continue to represent her. She described contacting the office by telephone and in person during the appeal period.
She eventually learned that she needed to reapply for representation on appeal. To avoid further delay, she decided to file on her own before Legal Aid made a final determination, but by then an extension was required.
On the written materials and her oral submissions, O’Brien accepted both a genuine intention to appeal in time and a reasonable excuse for missing the deadline in those circumstances.
Fairness favoured hearing both appeals
The relationship between the two custody decisions supplied a further, exceptional reason to extend time. The September decision referred to and accepted findings made in July, and considered whether S.R. had made progress in addressing the concerns previously identified.
Without an extension, S.R. could challenge the later order but could not appeal the earlier findings that featured prominently in it. Although each appeal concerned a different child and might raise some distinct issues, the evidence, parenting concerns and likely arguments overlapped substantially.
The judge considered the decisions so closely connected in timing and substance that it would be inappropriate to let one appeal proceed while denying the other. Refusing an extension could produce incongruous outcomes. Hearing the two continuous-custody appeals together was the fairer course.
That connection also shaped the treatment of potential merit. An extension application does not determine the appeal, and the applicant does not have to show that the challenge will ultimately succeed. O’Brien recognized the difficulty a self-represented person faces in identifying and explaining possible appellate errors.
S.R.’s arguments might or might not succeed, but substantially similar arguments would already be heard on the timely appeal. Allowing them to be advanced in both closely linked matters appeared to create no injustice. In these particular circumstances, potential merit was not determinative of the extension application.
Considering the factors together, O’Brien granted additional time. The ruling did not endorse S.R.’s allegations of error or reverse either custody order.
Interim-access appeal had lost its procedural basis
The Manager succeeded on the separate request to strike the interim-access appeal.
While one child was in temporary custody, S.R. had sought permission to bring an emergency interim application for immediate supervised parenting. A Supreme Court judge found that the requirements for permission were not met, and noted that a continuous-custody hearing was scheduled for the following month.
Once the continuous-custody order was made, the temporary setting for that application no longer existed. The proposed interim relief had been sought pending a final determination, which had since occurred. O’Brien therefore found it inappropriate to continue an appeal about permission to bring that temporary application.
Striking that notice did not remove S.R.’s right to challenge the continuous-custody order. To the extent her interim-access concerns or arguments were relevant, they could be included in submissions on the custody appeal.
The result left two continuous-custody appeals to be heard together. A hearing date could be requested after the necessary materials were filed, with further directions available if required. No costs were ordered on either application. The decision did not determine the eventual appeal outcomes or any subsequent parenting arrangement.
Source: S.R. v. Newfoundland and Labrador (Manager of Child and Youth Services), 2026 NLCA 13.



