
The Federal Court refused Enteractive Media permission to introduce new evidence in its appeal over the GAMECHANGERZ trademark, finding that credibility problems and the company’s explanation for its earlier inaction outweighed the evidence’s relevance.
In Enteractive Media Inc. v. Gamechanger Media, Inc., 2026 FC 843, decided June 19, Justice Angela Furlanetto dismissed both the request to file evidence and a related motion to amend the proposed affidavit. Costs were awarded to Gamechanger Media, with the amount left for agreement or further submissions.
A missed deadline and disputed notice
The Registrar had required proof of Canadian use during a three-year period ending November 25, 2024. Enteractive filed nothing by the deadline, and its registration was expunged in April 2025. On appeal, it maintained that the notice had not been received or had been misplaced.
Subsequent tribunal records included courier proof of delivery. The court found that the company’s director had received and signed for the notice. A separate warning letter from the opposing company’s lawyer had also been received and discussed internally before the evidence deadline.
The judge rejected the explanations that those communications had not been understood or remembered. The record also demonstrated experience handling trademark matters. The company had not supplied a reasonable explanation for failing to respond to the Registrar.
Materiality did not settle the leave question
The court applied the interests-of-justice test under subsection 56(5) of the Trademarks Act. Relevant considerations included the evidence’s relevance, credibility, admissibility and materiality, the circumstances of the delay and prejudice to the opposing party.
The proposed affidavit met relevance and materiality requirements: it concerned use of the mark, and the Registrar had previously received no evidence of use. But inaccuracies concerning the proposed witness’s corporate role and how customers paid for services undermined reliability. Proposed corrections did not resolve the broader concerns.
The court rejected the argument that non-use proceedings should attract a different leave test from trademark oppositions. The purpose of removing unused marks and the relatively low threshold for proving use did not eliminate the other factors. Nor did the procedure’s character make prejudice to the requesting third party irrelevant.
The judge distinguished cases where new evidence had been accepted without opposition. Here the explanation for delay was contested, prejudice was asserted and the court agreed that Enteractive had attempted to mislead it about awareness of the notice.
A procedural ruling, not a new use determination
The result denied permission to add the evidence; the court was not deciding afresh whether the mark had actually been used. With leave refused, the proposed-affidavit amendment was also denied. The ruling illustrates why evidence capable of affecting the Registrar’s decision can still fail the broader admission test.



