
B.C.’s Ministry of Health was ordered to release older ventilator-allocation records and limited administrative information, while retaining protection for much of its newer policy advice.
In Order F26-59, 2026 BCIPC 72, dated July 3, adjudicator Alexander R. Lonergan considered an access request made on behalf of Disability Alliance BC.
The disputed draft frameworks contained comprehensive recommendations for allocating scarce medical equipment. Removing comments and tracked changes would not prevent disclosure of that advice. Integrated background facts also remained protected.
But the advice exemption does not apply to records that have existed for at least 10 years. Lonergan assessed their age when deciding the inquiry, rather than when the ministry originally responded. He rejected adding a condition that old records could remain withheld because they might reveal similar, more recent advice.
The ministry also had to release specified information about administrative processes, equipment and a working group that did not reveal recommendations.
The compliance deadline was August 17. The ruling does not order release of every draft, decide the merits of medical triage policy, or establish subsequent compliance.



