
The City of Salmon Arm may withhold legal-advice records concerning a wildfire covenant on a resident’s property, B.C.’s privacy adjudicator ruled.
In Order F26-75, 2026 BCIPC 94, dated August 31, adjudicator D. Hans Hwang upheld withholding under the solicitor-client privilege exception to the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act.
The dispute concerned information in email chains and attachments, including presentation slides. After inspecting the records, Hwang found confidential requests for advice, lawyers’ responses and internal staff discussions of that advice. The slides were integral to the advice, while staff exchanges formed part of the protected communications.
The applicant sought to invoke the crime-fraud exception, arguing the city had obtained advice to support improper conduct. Hwang found the allegation unsupported by evidence and, having examined the records, found no evidence of crime or fraud.
The ruling concerns access to legal communications. It does not decide the covenant’s validity or allegations of professional misconduct. The city had already discharged the covenant in 2024; other withholding issues had been resolved before the privilege determination.



