
A Newfoundland and Labrador landlord failed to prove a damages claim despite persuading an adjudicator that a tenant’s behaviour genuinely caused discomfort.
In its September 28, 2026 decision 26-0541-NL, the Residential Tenancies Tribunal distinguished that reaction from proof of unreasonable interference. Both parties’ accounts were plausible, messages did not establish the alleged breach, and supporting witnesses had observed the landlord’s reaction rather than the disputed conduct.
The tenant nevertheless lost claims for a rent refund and moving-related expenses. The tribunal rejected alleged bad faith in the termination notice and held the tenant to an agreement to pay a full month despite moving in partway through it.
The landlord’s claim for the following month’s rent also failed: the tenant left by the date specified in the landlord’s notice, ending rental liability.
Only the outstanding $74.99 deposit balance was ordered repaid. The landlord had not timely applied against the deposit after receiving the tenant’s application, preventing consideration of the claimed utility deduction.



