The Federal Court has upheld a Canada Revenue Agency decision denying pandemic benefits to a claimant whose records did not establish her eligibility, while stressing that the result did not mean she had been dishonest when she applied.

In Nguyen v. Canada (Attorney General), 2026 FC 1234, Justice Avvy Yao-Yao Go dismissed Thuy Duong Nguyen’s challenge to the CRA’s second review of her Canada Emergency Response Benefit, Canada Recovery Benefit and Canada Worker Lockdown Benefit claims. The October 6 judgment, released after a court-ordered publication delay, made no costs award.

The court acknowledged that people may no longer possess all the documents needed when the CRA reviews claims years later. That does not establish deceit, Go said, but a lack of sufficient evidence can still result in benefits being clawed back. The judge also noted remission relief as a possible way to address hardship, without ordering or guaranteeing it.

A tax assessment did not settle benefit eligibility

Nguyen, who represented herself, challenged an October 1, 2025 second-review decision. She argued that the officer had not meaningfully engaged with her submissions and had failed to explain why the CRA’s earlier acceptance of C$6,000 in reported 2019 self-employment income was insufficient.

Her account centred partly on babysitting for her sister. An initial letter described work from August through December 2019. In seeking reconsideration, Nguyen said the work had stopped because the pandemic caused her sister to lose her job. She said payments had come through a joint account and offered to provide statements, but did not include those statements with her review request.

For CERB, the relevant issue was whether she had stopped working for COVID-19-related reasons. Go held that Nguyen bore the burden of documenting eligibility. A tax return did not itself prove that the reported income had been earned. The officer considered the bank statements supplied but found no record that validated the claimed babysitting income.

Nguyen also argued that the second reviewer had overlooked information given by telephone to the first reviewer, including that she had continued babysitting until March 2020. The court found that the first reviewer had not accepted that account as established. The notes recorded the claimed cash payments but said there were no deposits demonstrating babysitting income. The second reviewer’s treatment of the record was therefore not unreasonable.

Separate gaps affected the recovery and lockdown benefits

For CRB, Nguyen said she had met the minimum-income requirement through her 2019 self-employment and had suffered a complete income loss because she could not find work during the pandemic. The court found that these submissions did not resolve the missing record of the earlier income.

The second reviewer also identified two specific problems: Nguyen’s percentage share in a cleaning-business partnership could not be confirmed, and her bank statements did not show payroll deposits corresponding to pay stubs from Shiny Plus. Nguyen said the first reviewer had accepted that she owned half the partnership. Go nevertheless found it reasonable for the second reviewer to require confirmation in the documents provided.

The lockdown benefit issue was narrower. The reasons identify January 2–8, 2022 as the disputed week; eligibility for January 9–15 had already been accepted and was not challenged. The CRA’s review concerned whether income had fallen by the required 50 per cent. Nguyen made no submissions about CWLB eligibility in her request for the second review, and her reliance in court on the 2019 tax assessment did not overcome the evidentiary problem.

Across the benefits, Go rejected the argument that differences between the two reviewers’ explanations made the second decision unreasonable. Each officer had to conduct an independent assessment, and new evidence had been provided between reviews. A different explanation did not itself establish a reviewable error.

The fairness and language arguments also failed

Although several arguments were raised for the first time at the hearing, the judge considered them. They included complaints that the CRA had not adequately explained what was missing and should have requested documents in writing because English was not Nguyen’s first language.

The court found that a May 2024 letter had notified Nguyen of the review and the relevant eligibility requirements. Review notes showed that she had been told what was needed, and she had several opportunities to supply additional material. Her rights to know the case and respond had been respected.

On accommodation, the court found no record of a request by Nguyen or her sister. A one-time authorization for the officer to speak with the sister concerned confirmation of babysitting and a joint bank account. Go also noted that Nguyen made some submissions in English and had sworn her court affidavit in English without an interpreter, although her sister was allowed to interpret at the hearing.

The conclusion was expressly tied to that record: there was insufficient evidence of a need for accommodation or a request for it. The court found the second review procedurally fair and reasonable, leaving the eligibility decision in place without finding dishonesty or granting hardship relief.

Source: Nguyen v. Canada (Attorney General), 2026 FC 1234.