Four days before Vancouver’s municipal election, a B.C. Court of Appeal judge temporarily halted demolition of the Vancouver Aquatic Centre. In Protecting Our Vancouver Aquatic Centre Society v Vancouver (City), Justice Dickson gave the incoming Park Board a chance to reconsider what would happen to the centre’s 50-metre pool. The order ran only until November 3, the day after the new board’s inaugural meeting.

The dispute began with a question put to voters in 2022. The City sought authority to borrow $103 million to replace, renew or rehabilitate the aquatic centre. The information package sent to voters described plans to renew the 50-metre lap pool and the diving pool. The ballot itself said nothing about pool length. Voters approved the borrowing.

When detailed planning began, staff concluded that site, budget and scheduling constraints made it impractical to include a 50-metre pool alongside the other facilities. The Park Board approved a design with a 25-metre lap pool, a diving pool and a leisure pool. City council approved the revised budget.

The society and its director Jonathan Girard, who was running for the Park Board, challenged those decisions. In September reasons, B.C. Supreme Court Justice Giaschi held that the wording voters approved authorized borrowing for the revised project. He dismissed the petition. The society and Girard appealed. When a subcontractor began preparing the building for demolition on October 1, they asked the appeal court for a pause.

Both sides agreed the appeal raised a serious question. For Dickson, the immediate risk was that demolition could deprive voters of a meaningful choice before the October 17 election. Several candidates supported keeping a 50-metre pool. If enough of the building came down before the incoming commissioners met, money could never restore their chance to reconsider the project with the facility intact.

The City and Park Board pointed to the cost of delay. Their evidence put potential contractor claims at $172,500 for a stoppage between October 9 and November 3. They said hazardous materials would have to come out even if the building were renovated. Dickson found the evidence too general to tell what effect the work would have on the structure. She allowed the respondents to seek a change to the injunction on two clear days’ notice with detailed evidence that the proposed work would leave the building intact.

The judge considered a three-week pause modest in the life of an already long-delayed project. Her order settled neither the appeal over the City’s borrowing authority nor the choice of a pool design. Its November 3 deadline has passed.

Read the Court of Appeal’s reasons, 2026 BCCA 446.