B.C.’s Ministry of Health may continue withholding disputed information about proposed changes to the Family Compensation Act, under Cabinet confidentiality and legal privilege.

In Order F26-88, 2026 BCIPC 113, dated October 21, adjudicator Alexander R. Lonergan rejected an applicant’s challenge after the ministry had already released some information.

A summary of legal advice remained privileged even though ministry staff, rather than the lawyer, prepared the Cabinet submission containing it. The evidence established Cabinet as the client and the summary as an internal communication about its advice.

Other disputed information would reveal Cabinet’s proposed policy and implementation deliberations. Some factual background was inseparable from advice. Separate background material also remained protected because the relevant decision had not been made public or implemented, and five years had not elapsed.

Lonergan found the ministry had reasonably severed records where possible. Because Cabinet confidentiality and legal privilege resolved all disputed withholding, he did not decide the separate advice exemption.

The ruling determines access, not the merits of wrongful-death law reform or whether further legislative changes should occur.