
Alberta’s information commissioner ordered Environment and Protected Areas to disclose disputed portions of Compass Consulting Group’s 809-page campground-reservation proposal.
In Order FOIP2026-33, issued October 28, 2026, adjudicator Amanda Swanek rejected the company’s challenge to partial release. The request covered the reservation-system contract, bids and evaluation sheets, including pricing, from June 2017 to July 2019. Before the inquiry, the department gave the requester 158 pages with redactions. The requester did not challenge what the department had decided to keep confidential. It was Compass that sought review, arguing that the department proposed to release too much of its August 2017 bid.
The province’s FOIP guidelines explain the three-part business-information exception in section 16. Information must fall within a protected category, such as commercial information or trade secrets; have been supplied in confidence; and meet a specified harm condition. Those conditions include significant competitive or negotiating harm and undue financial loss or gain. The guide cautions that a confidentiality label alone is insufficient: the assertion needs evidence.
Compass had told the department that its methods reflected more than a decade of experience delivering services. Swanek found that many passages described project management in general terms. Some material appeared commercial, but in places she could see little difference between passages Compass wanted withheld and those it was willing to release. There was a further obstacle in the bid itself: where it addressed the tender conditions, Compass had said it considered no part of its proposal confidential. It filed no inquiry submission explaining why the adjudicator should read that statement differently.
The staff-turnover figures illustrated the missing link. According to the department, Compass said competitors could use the figures to understand its workforce and service practices. Neither its account nor the records explained how that insight would translate into significant competitive harm or undue financial loss or gain. Swanek likewise found no clear risk in brief descriptions of past projects. A nine-year-old bid could still contain sensitive information, but Compass bore the burden of showing how disclosure could cause harm. Facing stiffer competition on the next tender would not, by itself, meet that test.
Existing business-information and personal-privacy redactions, including withheld pricing, were outside this inquiry. The department was ordered to notify both Swanek and Compass in writing of compliance within 50 days of receiving the order.
The commissioner’s transitional guidance explains why older access proceedings can still fall under the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act after its repeal: requests made before the replacement legislation took effect continue under the former law.



