
A Nova Scotia physician may pursue judicial review of an appeal decision concerning his removal from a practice-ready assessment program, after the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia rejected an argument that the dispute was private and contractual.
In Onyeneho v. PACE, 2026 NSSC 334, Justice James L. Chipman dismissed the Physician Assessment Centre of Excellence (PACE)’s preliminary motion on October 28, 2026. Written reasons released October 29 explain why the appeal committee’s decision remained part of a public administrative process despite the program’s transfer to an independent non-profit corporation.
The court did not overturn the assessment decision, decide whether the physician was competent to practise or restore a medical licence. It decided that judicial review was available. PACE was ordered to pay Dr. Nnamdi Onyeneho $1,500 in costs forthwith, and the court was prepared to resume the motion for directions.
Government program changed structure during the appeal
The assessment centre began as a provincial Special Operating Agency in October 2024 under the Minister of Health and Wellness. Its program offered internationally trained physicians a pathway to further licensing by assessing their competence in office-based primary care.
Candidates needed a short-term Clinical Assessment Licence from the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Nova Scotia. Completing the assessment could lead to a recommendation concerning competence, but the College retained responsibility for licensing decisions.
Onyeneho entered a candidate contract in December 2024 and began his assessment in February 2025. The chief executive ended it after eleven days, stating that sufficient assessment evidence supported early termination. The contract allowed termination where specified deficiencies or concerns about the required competencies were demonstrated. The court did not adjudicate those underlying concerns on this motion.
The contract initially referred to an appeal under the Medical Act, but the legislation provided no process for reviewing decisions by PACE as a separate entity. The parties developed an internal review mechanism. A competence committee upheld the termination in July 2025, followed by an appeal process limited to procedural fairness or other significant procedural fault.
While that appeal was pending, the province revoked PACE’s agency designation. PACE Inc., incorporated as a non-profit with the College as its sole member, assumed the clinic and program on October 31, 2025. The appeal hearing and decision followed the transfer. In December, the appeal committee found no procedural unfairness or significant procedural fault. Onyeneho sought judicial review in January 2026.
The source and function of authority mattered
PACE argued that the appeal decision was not reviewable under Civil Procedure Rule 7.01. Judicial review generally requires an exercise of state authority with a sufficiently public character; not every decision by a public body qualifies. Ordinary contracts for premises or staff, for example, may involve private powers.
The court rejected treating physician assessment as an incidental business function. Assessing internationally trained doctors was central to PACE’s mandate, and this assessment process was closely integrated with the statutory licensing framework.
The appeal committee had been established while PACE was a government agency. Its terms required and received government approval, the deputy minister appointed its members and chair, and it reviewed a decision made within a government-operated program. The appeal began before the agency designation was revoked.
The licensing consequences reinforced that public character. The judge distinguished a case involving termination of a physician’s internal management appointment: Onyeneho was not PACE’s employee. Terminating his participation in the approved assessment caused his assessment licence to cease being valid under the regulations.
Internal participation did not waive court review
PACE also relied on Onyeneho’s agreement to take part in the internal process. The judge found that correspondence and submissions expressly reserved his right to judicial review. Agreeing to participate did not amount to abandoning that right.
More fundamentally, party agreement could not answer whether the committee was exercising governmental authority. A contract formed part of the relationship, but it operated alongside ministerial control, the agency designation, medical regulations, the statutory licence and the government-approved review structure.
The committee continued exercising the authority with which it had been constituted before the corporate transition. Its final decision was therefore reviewable. The ruling concerns this particular transitional process; it does not decide that every decision of a non-profit assessment organization is subject to judicial review.



