
B.C.’s Provincial Health Services Authority must release some records about implementing a 2021 vaccination order, but may retain privileged legal communications and genuine advice.
In Order F26-95, 2026 BCIPC 120, dated October 30, adjudicator D. Hans Hwang considered a health worker’s request for communications concerning the provincial health officer’s COVID-19 vaccination requirements.
PHSA and the Health Employers Association of BC relied on lawyer affidavits and a communications table. Hwang found sufficient evidence of confidential legal advice without inspecting the privileged records. Sharing advice among joint health-authority clients did not defeat privilege, and protected communications could not safely be severed.
The advice exemption had narrower reach. Editorial recommendations and certain interpretive advice remained protected, but neutral letter templates, operational instructions, attachment descriptions and routine email content did not reveal advice. Instructions communicating settled policy were different from recommendations a decision-maker could accept or reject.
PHSA must disclose the unprotected information by December 14. The ruling addresses access, not the vaccination order’s validity; a separate safety-based withholding claim was outside the inquiry.



