
A joint expert in a B.C. family property dispute must value the shares held by a trust connected to Boardwalk’s founders and separately assess one founder’s beneficial interest in that trust. Justice B. Hardwick directed the expert to use fair market value for both tasks, while reserving disputed questions of ownership and entitlement for the court.
The November 3 directions in Barnes-Morrison v Kolias arose after the expert’s draft report omitted both valuations. Chartered business valuator Derek Sanders had understood that neither fell within his instructions. Clair Barnes-Morrison asked the court to expand those instructions. Evangelos Kolias, known as Van, and the trustees opposed parts of her request.
The shares and the beneficiary’s interest
Barnes-Morrison and Van were in a relationship from about 2011 to April 2023. Van conceded they were spouses under B.C.’s Family Law Act if that law governed their dispute. Whether Alberta law applied remained unresolved. Hardwick was managing the case and expected to preside at a trial scheduled to begin April 26, 2027.
Van and his brother Sam established Boardwalk in 1984. It later became a publicly traded real estate investment trust, held through a network of private companies. The Sam and Van Kolias 2020 Family Trust owns 100 Class B common shares in Park Place Holdings Limited and 100 in Boardwalk Investment Ltd. The trust was created during the relationship and replaced an earlier discretionary trust.
Those shareholdings formed one pool of trust property. The trust deed did not require separate accounts for each person’s contributions or link a contribution to a particular beneficiary’s entitlement. The trustees could decide whether, when and how much to distribute, and could exclude a beneficiary. Van was both a trustee and a beneficiary. Hardwick described Sam as effectively controlling the trust because every valid trustee decision required his consent.
That structure made the distinction between the trust’s assets and Van’s interest important. His position as a discretionary beneficiary gave him no fixed entitlement to a portion of the property. The court therefore needed directions addressing both the underlying shareholdings and the value of his opportunity to receive benefits.
Why both companies must be valued
The trustees accepted that the expert could value the Park Place shares, which they identified as the assets Van had contributed. They opposed valuing the entire trust, arguing that the wider exercise would intrude into other family members’ interests and add disproportionate expense. Van adopted their position.
Hardwick agreed that the expert should stay within the trust valuation and leave other family members’ interests alone. But both companies’ common shares belonged to the trust. Their fair market values were therefore appropriate and necessary parts of the expert’s work. Questions about beneficial ownership between the brothers remained for the judge.
The expert must value those shares at May 15, 2020, when the trust was created, and August 31, 2026. Hardwick had selected the latter date after the earlier trial date was lost, allowing time for valuation and responding reports before the rescheduled trial. She left open the possibility of an update.
Fair market value as the starting point
Barnes-Morrison wanted a broader opinion on Van’s beneficial interest. She argued that a hypothetical sale to an arm’s-length purchaser could be unhelpful where no meaningful market existed. She asked that the expert be allowed to consider value to the owner, expected benefits and probability-weighted present values, along with alternative scenarios.
Van argued that assessing his interest would require decisions about control, trustees’ intentions, competing beneficiaries and future distributions that belonged to the court. Alternatively, he sought a fair-market-value opinion within the valuator’s expertise.
Hardwick considered both an earlier trial-level decision, Stober v Stober, and the B.C. Court of Appeal’s ruling in Cottrell v Cottrell. Cottrell recognized that a beneficial interest’s increase in value was a factual question requiring attention to the trust’s terms, administration and distributions. It identified matters a valuator might consider, but the appeal had proceeded without reliable valuation evidence. Stober had directly addressed obtaining an opinion from a jointly retained expert.
Following Stober, Hardwick directed Sanders to value Van’s beneficial interest at the same two dates using fair market value alone. B.C.’s statutory starting point required evidence of fair market value, including evidence that a particular interest might have no market value. The direction established the expert’s assignment while leaving the court to decide the disputed legal issues.
Hardwick also declined to let counsel prepare sets of alternative assumptions for that opinion. With multiple contested issues still to decide, she was concerned about the cost and scope of additional valuation exercises. Costs of these case-management directions will be dealt with in a final order after trial.



