The British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal has dismissed a former ferry commander’s remaining sex-discrimination complaint after finding that BC Ferries made a reasonable settlement offer that fulfilled the purposes of the Human Rights Code.

The decision is O’Brien-Hornsey v. British Columbia Ferry Services Inc. (No. 3), 2026 BCHRT 234, published by the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal.

The result was not an award of $20,000 or a finding that discrimination had not occurred. Vice-chair Devyn Cousineau assessed the offer on the assumption that Erin O’Brien-Hornsey would establish her remaining allegations, then decided that continuing the proceeding would not further the Code’s purposes.

O’Brien-Hornsey worked for BC Ferries from 2008 to 2020. Her remaining complaint concerned alleged workplace sexism, including insubordination, preference for male authority and sexist remarks while she was the only female commander on the MV Baynes Sound Connector during the relevant period. An earlier decision had already dismissed allegations concerning her suspension and termination.

BC Ferries offered $20,000 for injury to dignity, without admitting liability. The offer also included workplace training and policy review. It required withdrawal of the complaint but did not require a release. It was made openly, so the tribunal could consider it, and was to remain available for two weeks after the November 6 decision.

A reasonable settlement offer can justify dismissal under section 27(1)(d)(ii). The tribunal explained that an offer need not precisely duplicate what might be ordered after a hearing. It must adequately address both the individual harm and the broader remedial purposes of the legislation.

O’Brien-Hornsey sought independent training on conflict, bystander intervention and leadership, safer reporting arrangements and involvement by her union. The tribunal found the employer’s existing and promised measures responsive to the allegations. These included recurring online respectful-workplace training for staff and earlier in-person training. The union was not a party, and the tribunal could not compel it to participate.

Cousineau expressed concern that the policy-review commitment was vague and effectively unenforceable. She nevertheless accepted it as a good-faith, forward-looking measure, comparable in purpose to an order to stop discriminatory conduct and avoid repeating it.

The monetary component was at the upper end of what the remaining allegations could reasonably attract, the tribunal found. Injury-to-dignity compensation is remedial, not punitive. Harm attributed to termination could not increase the valuation because that part of the complaint had already been dismissed.

The allegations were serious, but the evidence of their impact was limited and had to be assessed within the surviving case. The tribunal also considered O’Brien-Hornsey’s position of authority. Her individual complaint was not a vehicle for a general inquiry into the employer’s workplace.

The tribunal concluded that public-interest concerns did not justify continuing despite the offer. The dismissal ended the proceeding; it did not establish that O’Brien-Hornsey accepted the offer or received payment.