The British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal has dismissed a complaint alleging that an independent police investigation was itself discriminatory, finding insufficient evidence to connect the investigators’ conduct to race or another protected characteristic.

The November 6 ruling in Radheshwar v. Abbotsford Police Department and another (No. 2), 2026 BCHRT 235 concerns how a misconduct complaint was investigated. It is not a fresh determination of whether the original police stop was justified.

Sundar-Jovian Radheshwar, a South Asian man, was stopped by New Westminster officers in July 2020 after they mistakenly believed he matched a suspect’s appearance. They left after determining he was not the suspect. Several separate complaints followed.

An earlier human rights hearing about the stop found some conduct inappropriate and unprofessional, but did not find racial profiling or discrimination. A separate complaint about the New Westminster Police Board’s investigation was also dismissed. The latest case concerned Sergeant Randy Riehl and the Abbotsford Police Department, which conducted an independent investigation into a second misconduct complaint.

Radheshwar alleged that the interview was hostile, that the report repeated inappropriate racial descriptions and that the investigators’ conclusion reflected a failure to understand systemic racism. The respondents denied discrimination and said the evidence did not connect any adverse treatment to a protected characteristic.

Tribunal member Carol Whittome recognized the social context of race-based over-policing. That context can help reveal discrimination in conduct that might otherwise appear ambiguous. It does not, however, create a presumption of discrimination or replace the need for evidence in the individual case.

The alleged hostility was supported only by general assertions and Radheshwar’s description of feeling discouraged. That did not take the claimed connection to race beyond speculation. The report’s repetition of another officer’s skin-colour description likewise lacked supporting contextual evidence from which discrimination could be inferred. Whittome did not rule that such descriptions can never be discriminatory.

The Police Complaint Commissioner had raised concerns about the misconduct analysis and appointed a retired judge to review it. But that appointment was an oversight step, not a decision overturning the investigators. The retired judge ultimately found the misconduct allegations unproven and described the investigators’ analysis as careful.

Whittome also distinguished unprofessional conduct during the original stop from discriminatory conduct by the later investigators. Even assuming the investigation did not address the unprofessionalism, that omission did not establish the alleged discriminatory explanation.

The tribunal was not reviewing the correctness of the retired judge’s decision or the investigation report. Its question was whether the investigation, report or resulting decision could reasonably be proved discriminatory. After considering the allegations individually and together, it found no evidentiary basis for that inference.

Radheshwar wanted a hearing to obtain further evidence. The tribunal said it had to decide the dismissal application on the material actually filed, not speculation about what might emerge later. A sincerely held belief and desire for accountability did not establish a reasonable prospect of success.

The complaint was dismissed under section 27(1)(c) of the Human Rights Code. This was a preliminary screening decision without findings on contested facts, rather than a new merits hearing on the police stop.

The respondent bore the burden on the dismissal application. The threshold for a hearing was low: the complainant did not have to prove the case at this stage, but the evidence had to move the alleged discrimination beyond conjecture.