A witness who could speak to when Ariana Bierman moved into Andrew Hanson’s home died before their family case reached trial. The two former partners disagreed over whether they had lived together long enough to qualify as spouses. In Bierman v Hanson, the B.C. Supreme Court dismissed Bierman’s claims for support and a share of the property after she took no meaningful step to advance them for six years and seven months.

Bierman said the couple had lived together for two years and 16 days. Hanson put the period at one year and nine months. The difference mattered because the statutory threshold at issue was two years in a marriage-like relationship. Bierman also claimed a beneficial interest in the Maple Ridge home for her contributions to the household. Hanson held title and said he had paid for the property and renovations. Justice Morellato left those competing claims about the relationship and the home undecided.

From two trial dates to six years without one

Bierman filed her claim in October 2017 and registered a certificate of pending litigation against the home. The following June, the parties agreed to exchange financial information, submit to questioning and set aside five days for trial. Both examinations took place. Bierman asked for each of the two scheduled trials in 2019 to be adjourned. Both were. Mediation that August ended without an agreement.

Financial disclosure remained incomplete. Bierman had acknowledged under questioning that she held U.S. accounts, but did not produce the records. Her sworn statements also omitted bank and credit card information, and she did not provide her 2017 Canadian tax return. The judge found that Hanson had substantially disclosed his own finances and that the missing information had already impaired his ability to question Bierman and assess her claims at mediation.

Hanson’s lawyer tried to move the case forward in 2023. Counsel ultimately spoke, but no hearing was arranged. Bierman’s position was that a full trial with live witnesses was needed. Her lawyer acknowledged that she sought no trial date in any year from 2020 through 2025. Only after Hanson applied for dismissal in March 2026 did she serve another notice to mediate and ask for a trial date.

Why the explanations fell short

Under B.C.’s family court rules, Hanson had to establish both that the delay was excessive and that it was inexcusable. The court then had to weigh whether the interests of justice still favoured a trial. The judge found the years of inactivity excessive, particularly given how much disclosure remained outstanding.

Bierman cited pandemic court backlogs, a change of ownership at her law firm and the cost of rebuilding her life after separation. The judge found no evidence that she had tried to get a hearing during the pandemic, or that the sale of the firm prevented her from instructing a lawyer. She had pursued the case for its first two years despite financial difficulties. There were no bank or credit card records showing how her circumstances had kept her from advancing it afterward.

What time had cost the defence

Bierman argued that the earlier examinations and sworn witness accounts had preserved enough evidence for trial. The judge found that testing the parties’ conflicting accounts would still depend on memories of events more than nine years earlier. The witness who died had firsthand knowledge of when Bierman moved in and of the work Hanson had done on the property. Older financial records were also at serious risk of being unavailable. Even if more could be produced, further questioning would be needed before trial.

There was a continuing cost outside the courtroom. The judge accepted Hanson’s evidence that the notice on title had prevented him from selling the home and moving his family. No broader public question called for a trial, and Hanson had repeatedly sought disclosure and tried to advance the case. Taken together, those circumstances weighed against allowing it to proceed. The judge dismissed the case for want of prosecution and awarded Hanson ordinary Scale B costs.

Read the B.C. Supreme Court’s reasons, 2026 BCSC 2166.