
Langley Township can withhold 26 pages of records involving an acoustic consultant its lawyers hired during a noise dispute with the Langley Rod and Gun Club. In Langley (Township) v British Columbia (Information and Privacy Commissioner), the B.C. Supreme Court found that the township was preparing for possible litigation even as it worked to bring the club into voluntary compliance.
Residents had complained about noise from the club, which began operating in 1946. The township adopted a noise bylaw in 2019 and inspected the property the following summer. Both sides sought legal advice. In November 2020, the club requested township records about noise complaints concerning its property and the surrounding area.
The township disclosed some material. Among the records it held back were communications between its outside lawyers and the acoustic consultant, including a draft report. In 2023, an adjudicator in the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner ordered the township to give the club access to those records. The adjudicator pointed to the township’s continued pursuit of voluntary compliance and the two years that passed before it issued three bylaw offence notices. The club disputed all three.
Justice G. R. J. Gaul examined what the township could reasonably have anticipated when the records were created in 2020. Its bylaw manager had given evidence that it was considering enforcement options if discussions failed. The judge also reviewed material filed privately. He found that the township could realistically expect litigation while still trying to resolve the dispute.
The second question was why the lawyers had hired the consultant. An expert’s work can serve more than one purpose. The judge found that the consultant was assessing issues directly connected to anticipated enforcement proceedings and that preparing for litigation was the main reason for creating the records. Requiring the township to rule out any other purpose would set the bar too high.
The judge set aside the part of the disclosure order covering the 26 pages and declared that the township could withhold them under section 14 of B.C.’s Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. He found the record complete and saw no need to send the matter back to the commissioner.



