
B.C. court orders new trial after family-law awards went unexplained
The appeal court says missing reasons prevented review of disputed property, damages and costs orders; the divorce itself was not challenged.
Section
Civil lawsuits and court proceedings across Canada, including liability, damages, contracts, property and estate disputes, class actions, settlements and enforcement.
417 stories
The appeal court says missing reasons prevented review of disputed property, damages and costs orders; the divorce itself was not challenged.

An Alberta judge says the existing class definition reaches members whose payments were withheld, even if they later settled, but refuses a disclosure-delay penalty.

The judge left the legality of federal clawbacks undecided and separately refused CNRL’s late $88,233.15 claim in the receivership.

B.C. court finds a rare potential duty to a represented non-client warrants trial; negligence, fraud and damages have not been finally decided.

Claims against two defendants were struck with leave to amend, while unjust enrichment remains. The court made no findings of fraud or conspiracy.

Both appeals were dismissed, but four judges found the patient's injuries were not too remote from her obstetrician's negligence.

Manitoba judge found no underlying civil or property right supporting the requested membership and oppression remedies; each side must bear its own costs.

Construction had continued despite earlier warnings of a stoppage. The judge also allowed the school to expand its claims over the North Vancouver project.

The estate seeks about $244,000 in legal expenses, less $48,000 recovered from the buyer. Its punitive damages claim against the listing agent can also proceed.

Federal class proceeding failed preferability test because provinces and child-welfare agencies were essential to fair resolution.

Court says the claim centres on management of academic work, not a civil action; allegations of diverted grant money were not findings of misconduct.

B.C.’s appeal court held that filing an earlier proposed class action, without any certification application, did not suspend these claims; it did not decide what caused the flood.

Credible oral evidence supported the existing award despite poor records on both sides; alleged deficiencies did not establish a basis for withholding payment.

With only the house’s foundation remaining, the panel finds no reviewable error in the denial of interim relief; the main injunction appeal remains undecided.

The Alberta court finds no triable separate employment or dependent-contractor relationship with AHS, despite its funding and control of the laboratory.

The court found the filing period extended through the next open day; the collision claim’s negligence and damages issues remain undecided.

An Ontario judge held Dylan James Sliter liable under a personal guarantee and construction trust provisions, while leaving the claims against two defending parties untouched.

Three errors led a judge to order independent oversight of the next annual meeting. He declined to undo the council election or invalidate a year of strata decisions.

The court found no basis to remove the executor or his lawyers and ordered tariff costs paid from the applicant’s share, leaving separate power-of-attorney litigation unresolved.

Nova Scotia judge dismisses both sides’ summary judgment motions, leaving contested research obligations and communications for trial.